4 ms·
> That simply isn't true. Nu-huh! C'mon. Is this what HN has come to? Look, I'm made an observation: put a kid in a room with three objects, 2 computers and
by niels_olson 11y ago
> That simply isn't true.
Nu-huh!
C'mon. Is this what HN has come to?
Look, I'm made an observation: put a kid in a room with three objects, 2 computers and 1 book, and in only one combination does he in fact learn python! He knows the terminal is on the iMac. I know he knows, because he knows how to ssh to another server to launch our Minecraft server. I've shown him python is there. But he doesn't use it.
He frankly seems quite proud of his "hacker laptop" that boots to console. He logs in, starts X, and gets a full-screen xterm running tmux. It even has an antenna sticking out. He thinks it's cool.
Fine. Whatever floats his boat.
But, seriously, if you're writing code, you are quite literally not doing any of the other things that you could be doing with that computer. E.g., browsing the internet, writing a document, drawing, etc, etc.
It's like saying "When I'm writing with this pencil, I'm not doing any of the other things I could be doing with this pencil." E.g., throwing it in the air, braking it in half, pulling the eraser out, sharpening it, whittling it down with a knife, splitting the wood to get the whole lead out, etc, etc.
I'm just stating a fact. There's no argument to be made there. If you want an argument, there are other things to argue about.
- sbuk 11y agoFact? No. Confirmation bias, certainly. The 'fact' that you are trying to assert is that kids can't learn to 'code' on an iMac, which is wrong (and also has nothing to do with the article). Before you argue that words being put in your mouth > Give him a 27" iMac and he learns to find and play meaningless random crappy Flash games, watch Minecraft videos, and occasionally play minecraft or do something else, like looks something up, checks his homework assignments, et I think that shows a remarkable lack of imagination. As a counter point, my nephew is happily learning Python on an iPad using both CodeAcademy online and the Pythonista app. When he wants to tinker, his dad will hook up the RPi he has. What I suspect happened here is the crappy laptop and BSD (iMac is also essentially running a BSD) was give as a "here, learn Python" and the iMac wasn't mentioned.