4 ms·
I implemented a SAML2 IDP once when I worked at a University using Shibboleth (as both the IDP and SP). SAML2 has a lot of heavy usage in academia or between i
by djsumdog 11y ago
I implemented a SAML2 IDP once when I worked at a University using Shibboleth (as both the IDP and SP).
SAML2 has a lot of heavy usage in academia or between industry systems. That being said, there were a lot of exceptions and rules that needed to be put into place for the plethora of broken SAML2 implementations. Some needed an attribute in two scopes, others had trouble with certain OIDs, etc. The Shibboleth mailing list is filled with things like, "oh if you're trying to connect to someone using Oracle SSO, add x y and z because their stuff is hopelessly broken."
I mean for the most part, it did just work. I see it as great when you want to build trust relationships, but in the general case, I think OpenID was simpler and better.
I still run my own OpenID. It gets me into ... StackExchange. It no longer works with Slashdot, gitorious, freecode and many other sites that have either stopped supporting it or gone under. Oh wait, it works with OpenStreetMaps too.
- iheartmemcache 11y agoYeah, my experience is precisely the same re: OpenID. Is that SAML2 IdP code open? Things have..slowly... improved within the SAML2 ecosystem, but if you've found a better alternative (SSO for the average Joe - preferably with 2FA a la YubiKey) let me know.
- thaeli 11y agoSimpleSAMLphp is quite straightforward; use the Yubikey auth source and you get their 2FA very easily. SAML2 will never be quite as easy to configure as OpenID in practice, but it's the least painful setup I've seen. (Yes, I include several of the big commercial authentication-as-a-service vendors in that comparison.) Having the ability to easily manipulate attributes at a per-SP level makes integrating with semi-broken vendor implementations much more practical. There are modules available to add OpenID and OAuth; I use the OpenID module in production and have been quite happy with it.