5 ms·
>Almost no one does. That's not even remotely true. Our justice system may be severely fucked in many ways, but it's not completely nonfunctional. But we hear
by andrepd 11y ago
>Almost no one does.
That's not even remotely true. Our justice system may be severely fucked in many ways, but it's not completely nonfunctional. But we hear about the problems whenever something goes wrong. The other 99.9 percent of the time when things go smoothly we don't even notice...
- quanticle 11y agoThere is a huge difference between things going smoothly and things being just. Something like 95% of cases in the US don't even go to trial. They're ended in a plea bargain, which allows the prosecutor to serve as both judge and jury. I do not think that is a sign of a healthy justice system, nor a sign of a justice system that actually pursues justice.
- an_account 11y agoAlternatively, it is the sign of a very healthy justice system. When cases are cut and dry there's no reason to go to trial. A basic example: I know I jaywalked, and I got caught, so I pay the already predetermined fine. Why wasted tons of resources taking everything to trial and redifing the system with every case?
- wolfgke 11y ago> I know I jaywalked, and I got caught, so I pay the already predetermined fine. Why wasted tons of resources taking everything to trial and redifing the system with every case? Why punish jaywalking?
- andrepd 11y agoThat's beside the point here, really.
- wolfgke 11y agoI don't think so (and it shows that you really didn't understand my argument). You claimed: > Why wasted tons of resources taking everything to trial With my sentence I wanted to point out that perhaps the problem is perhaps that part of the problem is that there are too many criminal offences - thus the judicial system is much too expense, which leads to the problem that most cases have to be regulated in the dubious way of plea bargaining.
- mindslight 11y agoIt certainly shows the proliferation of ridiculous criminal laws. How many of these "99.9 percent" of "just" cases are simply just persecuting someone for an invented victimless "crime"? If the questionable legality of walking across an empty street doesn't perfectly illustrate how our minds have been warped by a draconian sense of "justice", I don't know what could.
- mason240 11y agoYou stepping in front of my car, going through my windshield, and hurting me, is not victimless.
- mindslight 11y agoThis is exactly the type of knee-jerk reaction that perpetuates the status quo of immoral laws. In your scenario, there is a civil case for the accident. There can still be a criminal sanction if a pedestrian fails to avoid vehicles (that are obeying traffic laws). This does not change my example, which is an empty street.
- mason240 11y agoYou must also be against drunk driving laws, and just about every law. Waiting until after dangerous behavior causes damages, injury, or even death to to happen, then hiring a lawyer to sue to damages is terrible to way to organize society. It benefits the privileged on both sides and monetary payouts do not bring back dead people or cure lingering injures.
- andrei_says_ 11y agoBecause in a society believing in punitive justice, punishment is morally right. There's also restorative justice of course but it's more complex and does not bring the same simplistic carnal satisfaction.
- quanticle 11y agoThe core principle of the US system of government (and of the British system that precedes it) is that no single person should have absolute power in a criminal trial. Power should be subject to checks and balances, even if those checks and balances are cursory in 95% of cases. Put another way, the US criminal justice system is the equivalent of a software development process where the vast majority of changes go in without code review.
- harryh 11y agoThat's wrong. The defendant and their lawyer are doing a code review.
- zhemao 11y agoThen like doing a code review in which the reviewer is underpaid and overworked and may not have access to the full code.
- warfangle 11y agoMost people arrested have to use a public defender. Public defenders have something like less than five minutes to even review the case file before going in front of the judge.
- foota 11y agoI really don't think we're talking about jaywalking cases here. (source, 2000: http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/dccc.pdf http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/dccc.pdf)
- adregan 11y agoSome of these folks are taking plea deals to get out on time served. That time they are serving? It's accrued while they are waiting to go to trial. In a hideously over crowded prison system with overworked public defenders, the right to a speedy trial is a thing of the past. Here is a particularly terrible story of this kind: http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/10/06/before-the-law http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/10/06/before-the-law Tragically, the young man from the story committed suicide last year: http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/kalief-browder-1993-2015 http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/kalief-browder-1993-...
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat's not true if prosecutors can lie about strength of case with immunity plus have a ton of leverage. Great explanation by this former prosecutor and judge: http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2014/11/20/why-innocent-people-plead-guilty/ http://www.nybooks.com/articles/2014/11/20/why-innocent-peop...
- andrepd 11y agoThat is a very good point. It's indeed a good indicator of how wrong things are. I don't live in the US, though. I was referring to the judicial system in the western world in general, not the US in particular.
- foobarian 11y agoThis topic came up with a friend's uncle once, who was an older Sicilian fellow with lots of first hand underworld exposure. He laughed at us as naive and claimed that the main purpose of the US justice system is to prevent vigilanteism.
- rubberstamp 11y agoand private arbitration clause included in most TOS agreements now a days. It doesn't work to provide justice as lawyers on company payroll will favor the company.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- _yosefk 11y agoGenerally, however funny or bad this sounds, justice isn't the only objective of a justice system - various kinds of impact on behavior are other reasonable goals (you might believe three strike laws to be just but oppose them because it incentivizes to murder witnesses), as is lowering the cost of the justice system itself (a treatment of every case that is just in isolation might not be a good or even a just deal for society if it costs taxpayers $100M to process each case, even if it's relatively trivial.) (I'm not saying that any specific justice system is good or bad, just that justice shouldn't be its only goal, which I think is an intuitively obvious point for most but a very contentious point for some.)
- songshu 11y agoI'm not sure what the original commenter meant, but some of us (a minority I'm sure) believe that no person deserves arrest, prosecution and jail in the forms they exist today even if that person is guilty of a crime. Things can go "smoothly" but still result in people being subjected to intimidation, cruelty and violence.
- andrepd 11y agoBy smoothly I mean not "nice and quiet" even if unjust, I meant lawfully and justly. I'm sad as everyone should when intimidation, cruelty and violence happen under law enforcement and/or the judicial system. Yet I can still recognised that this is not always the case. And that the silent majority of cases happen with no incident, but we don't hear of those. We do hear about the scandals, though.
- aljones 11y agoIt is very effective at locking up a huge number of people.
- id 11y agoThere are literally thousands of cases that: .) no one ever hears about .) are never reported by the media .) aren't "scandals" (to me they are) .) aren't just, as I (and probably others) see it I am talking about petty crimes that shouldn't even end up in court (Aaron is a good example), drug offences, more serious crimes with way too harsh sentences, juvenile offenders tried as adults, mental illness treated as a crime, things like the felony murder rule and so on and so forth. Mind you, I'm not talking about downright wrong verdicts (of which there are enough) here.
- crypto5 11y ago> The other 99.9 percent of the time when things go smoothly we don't even notice... Or just don't care if it really goes smoothly.
- ericd 11y agoI don't think 99.9% is accurate at all, unless you're including really routine things like traffic tickets.
- rhizome 11y agoJust to incorporate both of yours' points, I hope we all can agree that the CFAA is rank garbage.
- cookiecaper 11y agoIronically the biggest supporters of the current iteration of the CFAA are those you'd least expect. The currently-extant grey area allows them to target little guys and threaten them with spectacular, life-destroying threats, while also allowing them to abuse and/or ignore the law because they know that it's very unlikely another big entity will care enough to choose to litigate the issue to a conclusion (a process which often takes the better part of the decade). If the CFAA were not selectively enforced, the internet landscape would look very different. Search engines like Google never would've been able to exist. Who can quantify what we've lost because a big corporate interest threatened a small innovator with jail time and financial ruin if they didn't stop causing a problem for BigCorp's business, which actually turns out being a pretty good summary of Aaron's case.