16 ms·
Aaron Swartz died three years ago today
- Findeton 11y agodep
- mahouse 11y agoiyo ya vale
- coppolaemilio 11y agoEvery time I remember Aaron's story makes me angry. He is and will be a big inspiration for me.
- puppetmaster3 11y agoSame here.
- nickbauman 11y agoThis historical event is what tipped me into the direction of being much, much more concerned about government overreach and find some sympathy with my libertarian-leaning friends for the first time. Swartz's story will be part of The Fire Next Time that James Baldwin wrote about 40 years ago. Swartz is part of the same story that includes Eric Gardner, Sandra Bland, et al.
- rabidonrails 11y agoA Swartz is more closely related to general government overreach like Snowden or Katherine Mitchell; people who saw a system that needed fixing. Comparing A Swartz with Gardner is a somewhat unfair comparison for Swartz.
- gertef 11y agoIs downloading information less worthy of government regulation then trading cigarettes? Is hounding someone through the courts more of an overreach than killing in the street?
- wolfgke 11y agoWhile Swartz was surely a lot more of a hero then Eric Garner, both were each in their own way murdered (or left for dead) by the same system of criminal prosecution.
- ktamura 11y agoI just got this book in the mail that collected aaronsw's writings: http://www.amazon.com/Boy-Who-Could-Change-World-ebook/dp/B00VPPYEQK/ http://www.amazon.com/Boy-Who-Could-Change-World-ebook/dp/B0...
- manaskarekar 11y agoI often remember his essay 'Lean into the pain' : http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/dalio http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/dalio
- krat0sprakhar 11y ago+1. His series on Raw Nerve is still one of the best things that I've found on the internet - http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/rawnerve http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/rawnerve
- ameen 11y agoWhile it's a decent read, objectively it means that his way of life failed and he accepted failure by taking his own life. P. S. I'm in no means condoning what happened to him, it's a great injustice but ultimately Aaron didn't persevere as he himself has written.
- 5db8db 11y agoHe is such a inspiring legend, shining beside Edward and the other fighting friends, for freedom and a better world. I love Aaron for his spirit and the mission he lived. For anyone, who hasn't seen the documentary [1], I can recommend it! Good to be remembered to some of his goals: „We need to buy secret databases and put them on the Web. We need to download scientific journals and upload them to file sharing networks.“ [2] [1] https://freedocumentaries.org/documentary/the-internet-s-own-boy-the-story-of-aaron-swartz https://freedocumentaries.org/documentary/the-internet-s-own... [2] http://archive.org/stream/GuerillaOpenAccessManifesto/Goamjuly2008_djvu.txt http://archive.org/stream/GuerillaOpenAccessManifesto/Goamju...
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI independently came up with the same thing about journals but instinctively knew better. I looked at the financial reports for a major one to confirm or reject the instinct. All I can say is "Holy shit. We're not buying that any time soon." Thanks for the documentary link, though. I'll check it out.
- xiaoma 11y agoHe was a pretty argumentative guy, but he was right about so much. He genuinely put his heart into what he believed in. Without him (and Lessig), SOPA easily could have gone the other way. He didn't deserve what the justice system did to him. Let's be honest. Almost no one does. Aaron is definitely missed.
- kragen 11y agoI argued with Aaron a lot. He changed his mind a lot. When he didn't change his mind, it was almost always because I was wrong. In that way, he was the humblest person I have ever met.
- andrepd 11y ago>Almost no one does. That's not even remotely true. Our justice system may be severely fucked in many ways, but it's not completely nonfunctional. But we hear about the problems whenever something goes wrong. The other 99.9 percent of the time when things go smoothly we don't even notice...
- quanticle 11y agoThere is a huge difference between things going smoothly and things being just. Something like 95% of cases in the US don't even go to trial. They're ended in a plea bargain, which allows the prosecutor to serve as both judge and jury. I do not think that is a sign of a healthy justice system, nor a sign of a justice system that actually pursues justice.
- an_account 11y agoAlternatively, it is the sign of a very healthy justice system. When cases are cut and dry there's no reason to go to trial. A basic example: I know I jaywalked, and I got caught, so I pay the already predetermined fine. Why wasted tons of resources taking everything to trial and redifing the system with every case?
- 11y ago
- sethbannon 11y agoI encourage everyone to take time today to reflect on Aaron's legacy, and on how we can use technology to make the world more just, more open, and more fair.
- kevinoid 11y agoFor those interested in commemorating in person, there are events planned in Atlanta, Chicago, Dallas, NYC, and SF https://info.thoughtworks.com/celebrate-aaron-2016 https://info.thoughtworks.com/celebrate-aaron-2016 and Seattle https://mako.cc/copyrighteous/celebrate-aaron-swartz-2016 https://mako.cc/copyrighteous/celebrate-aaron-swartz-2016
- jason_slack 11y agoI just watched "The Internets Own Boy" again last night. It amazes me what our justice system can do to people and not be held responsible. Had I done the same thing to Aaron, I'd have been given lethal injection by now.
- escherize 11y agoYou don't become a ruler to be subject to the rules.
- jason_slack 11y agoIf I had known growing up that the country I lived in was like this, I'd of not cared about it so much. I used to stand when the national anthem would come on and deeply be thankful for what I had.
- david927 11y agoFirst, Aaron was as much our country as the people who persecuted him. He cared about it; you should too. You can react two ways: 1) impotent anger or 2) stand up and continue his fight. Which will it be? Find friends and others and we can all pitch in to create a method of distributing knowledge in a way that can't be controlled. The internet makes it possible, the only thing missing is the will and the effort. Anyone can contact me: my email's in my profile.
- jason_slack 11y agoI'm not angry. But I am disappointed to the point I think we need serious reform. This means a call to action. This is what Aaron did.
- wolfgke 11y ago> I'm not angry. But I am disappointed to the point I think we need serious reform. This means a call to action. Aaron can't do this an anymore since he was driven into suicide by the criminal prosecution of his country, he can't do it anymore. So: Don't call for action - act instead!
- jstoiko 11y ago"Sign the Petition for Better Oversight for Federal Attorney Misconduct" http://www.takepart.com/internets-own-boy#takeaction http://www.takepart.com/internets-own-boy#takeaction
- hkmurakami 11y agoSeems like an apt time to reupload the markdown dump of his blog that was made by a HN'er 3 years ago. (we were concerned that his blog would cease to be a going concern) http://s000.tinyupload.com/index.php?file_id=67300433887705295405 http://s000.tinyupload.com/index.php?file_id=673004338877052... (not really sure where the best file hosting venue is these days)
- rpgmaker 11y agoSomeone actually made a perfectly indexed epub back then but I think HN frowns upon the reformatting of someone's public blog, which I guess is why more people don't upload an epub of pg's blog.
- cooper12 11y agoLooks like they established a GitHub repo, with additional formats available: https://github.com/joshleitzel/rawthought https://github.com/joshleitzel/rawthought
- slapresta 11y agoHe did not "die", he was murdered.
- wolfgke 11y agoLet's rather say: The deadly consequences were hazarded.
- gnaritas 11y agoNo he was not murdered; he committed suicide rather than face jail and fight. Using hyperbolic language and calling a suicide murder doesn't do anything useful.
- wolfgke 11y agoHe wouldn't have attempted suicide if he hadn't been confronted with the merciless system of prosecution.
- gnaritas 11y agoHe didn't have to commit suicide, that was his choice, you cannot blame his choice on those prosecuting him. People get prosecuted every day and serve time and don't go and kill themselves. He was not murdered. Murder means an unlawful killing; prosecutors did not unlawfully kill Aaron, he did that himself.
- wolfgke 11y ago> He was not murdered. Murder means an unlawful killing; prosecutors did not unlawfully kill Aaron, he did that himself. Carmen Ortiz as the prosecutor was the law at that moment, so it is a circular reasoning and sophistry to say that killing Aaron Swartz was not unlawful. > He didn't have to commit suicide, that was his choice And it was Carmen Ortiz' choice to bring Aaron into a position where he didn't see any other escape than suicide.
- 11y ago
- bitmapbrother 11y agoI'm still disgusted by the behavior of the MIT officials in all of this. Whenever I see or hear 'MIT' the first thing that comes to mind is: "that's the school that was responsible for the death of Aaron".
- gnaritas 11y agoAnd why would that come to mind when none of it is true? Firstly, Aaron is responsible for his own death, it was suicide. Secondly, it's the zealous prosecutor you should be mad at, MIT is not to blame here; Aaron broke many laws and they were well within their rights to have him arrested. Good intentions aside, what Aaron did was illegal and he deserved to be arrested for it; what he didn't deserve was more than probation and a slap on the wrist.
- dlandis 11y agoWell oftentimes colleges can and will exercise discretion when it comes to having a student arrested and they will perform their own internal inquiry to determine whether an offense warrants arrest and prosecution. That's just the way it goes. Colleges should do the right thing for their students and protect them when appropriate because all kids do stupid things. MIT would have known pretty well what type of prosecution he would face. Do you think all students who do something illegal on campus get arrested for it?
- gnaritas 11y agoHe didn't just do some silly illegal thing; he illegally hacked a network from a closet he should not have been in and hit it with so much traffic that he caused legitimate users of the network to suffer loss of access for multiple days and he did this multiple times after being kicked out. Legitimate users were harmed, regardless of what what anyone feels, Aaron committed a felony and was rightfully arrested. Beyond that, you seem to be overlooking the fact that it wasn't MIT that was after Aaron, but JSTOR, who constantly pushed MIT to help them locate the hacker who was taking their data from the MIT network. MIT didn't have the option to just handle the matter internally, a third party was involved who was being hacked through the MIT network. You know what happens when you're a hacktivist; you go to jail. Aaron knew he was guilty, he knew he was breaking the law when he did it, it was willful civil disobedience by his own admission. His suicide was likely the result of his knowing jail was coming even if the prosecutor hadn't been overzealous because he committed a felony and knew it and he couldn't deal with facing the consequences of his actions. He wanted to change the system, he went about it the wrong way and figured that out too late.
- mei0Iesh 11y agoThe response to his death is creepy to me, like "His name is Robert Paulson". There's so much misinformation, and misuse of his death for ideological and social purposes unrelated to the actual person. The fact that someone made something called "Internet's Own Boy" only compounds this. If it were me, I'd want to come back to life just to tell you all that I'm not your puppet, and you have no clue why I died; you didn't know me, and I am not "your boy". Since I couldn't come back to life, I'd hope there'd be people who would speak against this groupthink on my behalf.
- cooper12 11y agoDid you actually watch the documentary? (It's available for free) They talk with people who were very close with him, including his father, his ex-girlfriend, and Lawrence Lessig. It also includes excerpted footage of him speaking at various events. (Not to mention his blog is still present) If these people (like the author) and excerpts don't actually know Aaron Swartz, then I don't know who could. (I'm also of the personal opinion that documentaries are not meant to tell the truth, but rather solidify a living memory of the person) One can't deny that Aaron was opposed to institutional corruption (such as his work with PACER) and wanted to see the freedom of information (see his "Guerrilla Open Access Manifesto" for a precursor to that). Of course as in Fight Club, the original intent of a movement or a person's identity can get twisted and morphed, but it would help if you actually bought up these inaccuracies. The most insulting thing we could do is forget what Aaron fought for and let all that he stood for go for nought out of some misguided respect for his memory.
- SFjulie1 11y agoian murdock died less than 1 month ago too. He was right too. The news is still confined to the dead dogs section in local news. I guess that cemeteries are full of important people we all care about, sometimes much more than the yet to be important that are still alive.
- BenoitEssiambre 11y agoI wanted an Aaron Swartz t-shirt so I made these graphics: For dark fabric: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6fL4G1FVF-AdHhCdVU4UHhCNk0/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6fL4G1FVF-AdHhCdVU4UHhCNk0... For lighter fabric: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6fL4G1FVF-AblFNYlBrWTJmems/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6fL4G1FVF-AblFNYlBrWTJmems... Source Inkscape SVG: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6fL4G1FVF-AbHB3ZW9CZWNDVmc/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6fL4G1FVF-AbHB3ZW9CZWNDVmc... Based on a photo by Sage Ross (CC BY-SA) http://ragesoss.com/blog/2013/07/12/the-use-aaron-swartz-photographs/ http://ragesoss.com/blog/2013/07/12/the-use-aaron-swartz-pho... I printed one on zazzle.com on a dark t-shirt but it seems I can't share the design without becoming some kind of t-shirt vendor and take a royalty which I don't care to do. If you want one, you will have to upload the image yourself.
- flashman 11y agoYou can upload them to redbubble.com and set your royalty to 0%.
- SocksCanClose 11y agoI wonder what he would say about #jesuismilo.....
- ratsimihah 11y agoRIP Aaron!
- xyzzy4 11y agoI think he should've just taken a plea deal and gone to prison for a few months. It wouldn't have been that bad - maybe he could've taken the time to write a book.
- ameen 11y agoOne of the first movies I watched on Netflix (we just got it) was "The Internet's own boy". He was the typical overachiever, successful in almost anything he touched but finally he decided to hack justice. And broke a bunch of laws and went against a few institutions. JSTOR wasn't responsible, MIT might've been but he broke through enough barriers set up by them that Aaron did deserve a slight tap on his knuckles (the plea deal). And rather than take it he decided to end his life cause it meant the end of his political career. If he had been so volatile I wonder how he would've reacted had his earlier efforts elsewhere had failed.
- suprgeek 11y agoMIT Failed him - spectacularly so. If they had declared that they had no wish to see him in prison and used their (considerable) influence he would be alive. Instead, this political, vindictive creature http://wgbhnews.org/post/carmen-ortiz-spotlight-under-fire http://wgbhnews.org/post/carmen-ortiz-spotlight-under-fire and her nasty acolytes in search of a high profile "Scalp" pushed him over the edge. A terrible waste and a horrible use (misuse) of prosecutorial discretion.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoSeems like a good place to drop the Ableson report http://swartz-report.mit.edu/docs/report-to-the-president.pdf http://swartz-report.mit.edu/docs/report-to-the-president.pd...
- ryanlol 11y ago>he would be alive. How do you know? Aaron had been talking about suicide years before this, maybe we should just blame reddit? Edit: Why the downvotes? Fact is that we don't know why Aaron killed himself, but we do know that he had a prior history of depression and in 2007 posted what seemed very much like a suicide note. Frankly, making claims like "If x had (not) done y he'd still be alive" and presenting them as facts is straight up disgusting.
- 746F7475 11y agoWell, there are always the tinfoil-hat-theories
- pluma 11y agoWe don't know whether he would still be alive. We do know he wouldn't have been in the situation in which he ended his life. Claiming that victims of depression who have killed themselves would have killed themselves anyway is no less disgusting.
- ryanlol 11y agoWe really don't know how much of an effect MIT declaring that they don't want Swartz in prison would've had on his prosecution, speculating on that is rather pointless anyway since we never got to hear his sentence. I never made such a claim. I specifically brought up the previous depression to make clear that we really don't know what was going on his life and what ended up driving him over the edge.
- gravypod 11y agoCan anyone give a clear and concise summary of what he did to bring on the wrath of the criminal justice system? Every article I have read jumps back and fourth through his timeline and inter-splices useless information. I know it involves breaking into a room, writing a bot to scrape a website, and MIT. I'm not sure on the details though.
- cooper12 11y agoHe downloaded a large amount of articles from JSTOR. This involved setting up a laptop in a storage room in MIT, where he was not a student. MIT had to investigate it because the laptop was making a large amount of requests to JSTOR's servers and JSTOR had to block access to MIT. The rest of the story involves an overzealous federal prosecutor wanting to charge him under the CFAA to make an example of him because of Aaron's "Guerrilla Open Access Manifesto". JSTOR also claimed that Aaron cost them an overinflated sum of damages, but was not interested in prosecution after Aaron agreed to delete the acquired documents. MIT adopted a policy of neutrality in the matter, contrary to its spirit of hacking, and did not speak up for Aaron's case. Hope that helps. If you want a more objective look at the case, see Wikipedia [0][1] and MIT's Report to the President [2] (which is long, but very comprehensive). [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz#JSTOR https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz#JSTOR [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Swartz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Swartz [2]: http://swartz-report.mit.edu http://swartz-report.mit.edu
- marincounty 11y agoI don't mind argumentative. I look back on the people who changed a bad/given situation, and they raised that hand. The true bad asses walked, or got even. I have a question about Aaron Schwartz. Would he even be on Hacker News? Would he put up with the political correctness. Would he put up with "arse kissing"? Would he put up with a moderator who emailed him? I say this in light of an email I received from a moderator, I believe his name was Daniel? He stated my comments were not adding to the topic, and I should just, essentially go away. 1. I was shocked HN emailed me. I don't remember giving them permission. I'm trying to remember if I even signed a TOS, or even gave up an email? I think I once left my email up to recommend a medication, but took it down the next day. 2. Anyways email me again Hacker News. It's going into a file. Why on earth would you think it's legally permissible to email me. It's considered spam--right? 3. Hell-ban me--fine, but don't ever email me. Pass it by Hacker News lawyers? I'm still in shock. I'm not sure how to handle this of it escalates. I said some pretty personal things on this board. I do not want to be outed. I just falsely trusted Hacker News. 4. Bye! Oh yea, it's turned into a cliche, but the world needs, especially now, more Aaron Schwartz's. We have too many over zealous individuals/enetites in power. Our every move is recorded. And I look around, and I'm seeing less, and less people who question authority. (bumper sticker 90's?)
- CRConrad 11y ago"2. Anyways email me again Hacker News. It's going into a file. Why on earth would you think it's legally permissible to email me. It's considered spam--right?" Wow. So many misconceptions... Is there even _any part_ of the above that is correct?!? Your e-mail is just like your physical mail-box: Anyone can mail you something any time. That's what it's FOR.
- derrickdirge 11y agoIt's pretty gross the way you've made this memorial thread all about you. This seems like the exact wrong place to air your personal grievances against HN.
- lkiernan 11y agoCould you have picked a better thread to make some irrelevant rant? To address your only relevant question; I think he may have enjoyed interacting with the very smart people here. He also joined (merged?) the reddit team through ycom.
- dredmorbius 11y agoRelated: I'd run across an article some time back that discussed what it was that Aaron might have been up to by doing massive data collection of JSTOR data. Unfortunately I cannot find the article and don't recall just what it suggested. The upshot though was that there may have been some quantitative / bulk analysis that such a corpus would have allowed or enabled, potentially turning up interesting or unusual elements of large-scale academic research. Is this ringing bells with anyone?
- notindexed 11y agoThe irony of the surveillance video freely available on the web vs the scientific docs he downloaded.
- draaglom 11y agoFunny seeing the difference between then and now: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4529484 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4529484 Next time, let's try being this supportive before someone dies as well as after.
- ravin1729 11y agoan idealist to the core who has left a mark on world or anyone who got to know about him directly or indirectly. May be governments and people like us have failed him. Its like few or majority hold too much of power to make a decision rather than what is right.
- devhead 11y agoand still PACER is charging for searches. rip swartz
- swagv 11y agoI don't miss him one bit
- dang 11y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly violating the HN guidelines.