3 ms·
I made the argument that I did because the public justification for the NSA is terrorism. But I could have made a different argument focused only on the merits
by btilly 11y ago
I made the argument that I did because the public justification for the NSA is terrorism.
But I could have made a different argument focused only on the merits of spying.
Yes, it is obviously helpful to steal secrets. Yes, this gives us an edge in negotiations, allows us to steal technologies, and so on.
However people get pissed off at us when they discover that we have done so. See Angela Merkel's cellphone. Some of our attempts to assist spying leave us open to harm. See backdoors deliberately left in software that black-hats later discover. Lack of trust has a cost. I've seen estimates that US companies have lost tens of billions of dollars in contracts because other countries don't trust us with their data.
And when everyone knows that we spy, everyone else is likely to spy back just to level the playing field. But spying is asymmetric; small players can do it effectively with very little in the way of resources, and big players have more to lose.
When I put together everything I know, I believe that our aggressive spying programs are a net economic loss for us. We could be better off by spying in a much more targeted way, but with very large penalties for anyone who we caught spying on us.
Obviously I have biases and incomplete information. But I'm not convinced that spying is a good justification for the NSA, even if we were honest with ourselves about it.
- javajosh 11y ago>other countries don't trust us with their data. To riff on this, the reason is a cultural issue regarding the value of self-restraint. Self-restraint is no longer valued. In fact, self-restraint is considered a critical weakness. To not take any action you can get away with, that advances your interests, is weak. It's lack of value is written in stories of police brutality, it's written in the manner in which popular elections are conducted, it's written in the policies of our executive agencies, and it's written in the way business is conducted. Confronted with clear evidence of wrong-doing, leaders are no longer expected to apologize and resign; we expect them to deny, to resist, to fight to the bitter end, no matter what. They wait out the public, they wait out the courts, and they win. The question that I am having a hard time answering is simply: how did it get this way? Bush had a profound impact on this culture; there was a man who knew the anti-value of self-restraint! The anti-value of self-reflection, of taking responsibility for mistakes. Wall Street learned the anti-value of self-restraint, because they gambled, lost big, and got bailed out anyway. Police are taught the anti-value of self-restraint, because there is risk to the officer when using too little force, but virtually no risk to the officer when using too much. Power delegitimizes itself when it shows a systematic lack of self-restraint.