6 ms·
I deliberately made my analysis overly conservative because I didn't want to come off as a paranoid nut. I could have easily come to much higher figures. Here
by btilly 11y ago
I deliberately made my analysis overly conservative because I didn't want to come off as a paranoid nut. I could have easily come to much higher figures.
Here is an example. Let's suppose that we're observing the USA at a random point in its history. Then there is a 10% chance that we're looking at it within the last 10% of its history. The USA turns 240 this year, so that means that there is a 10% chance of it collapsing in the next 24 years.
That figure is much, much higher than the 1% odds I used of collapse in the next 30 years. It is also likely to be more realistic. "Stable governments" survive in periods measured in centuries, not millennia. However that number is so high that it would have left me more easily dismissed as a paranoid nut, so I avoided it.
History demonstrates that humans tend to over-estimate the stability of whatever exists now. And are surprised when the present turns out not to be permanent. You should try to compensate for such perceptual biases when you find them in yourself. And should try not to trip such biases in others.
- moheeb 11y agoCan you explain the math as to how you know there is a 10% chance that we're seeing the US in the last 10% of its history? I don't understand that part.
- charrisku 11y agoHe's saying that if you looked at the whole history of the US and divided that into 10 equal parts, then there would be a 10% chance of any random observation falling into the last part. Hence, all else equal, we have a 10% chance that we are looking at the US in the last 10% of it's history.
- hamburglar 11y agoThis would imply that there is also a 10% chance we are currently looking at the first 10% of the country's existence, which means you have confidently calculated the odds of the USA lasting at least 2350 years at 10% based on absolutely nothing. These probabilities are nonsense.
- btilly 11y agoIf we assume that we're observing at a random point in our history, we are equally likely to be observing at a point in the first 10%, second 10%, third 10%, and so on. That's what the assumption means. Which means there is a 10% chance that we're observing in the last 10%. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_argument https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_argument for the most famous use of this line of argument. (It concludes that the human species is likely not long for this universe.)
- Kluny 11y agoThere's something seriously squirrely about that math.
- grillvogel 11y agoI really don't think thats true and I also don't think that your doomsday argument link relates to what you are claiming either.
- btilly 11y agoThe conclusion absolutely follows from the assumption. But there are two questions. 1. Is that a reasonable assumption to make? (In a surprisingly wide variety of cases, yes. But not always.) 2. How do we update the conclusion of the argument given a variety of other information that we have available to us? For example we have a great deal of information about the US system of government, current political state, potential threats, and so on.
- grraaaaahhh 11y agoWhat's stopping us from applying this math to other things? Like, every baby at the 1 minute mark of their life. Shouldn't that mean that ~10% of all babies born dies within a minute and a half? We can take this to extremes. At the 1 minute mark we have a 99% change of being in the latter 99% of their life (and thus a 99% chance of dying 99 minutes later). It's amazing how many of them beat these odds.
- 11y ago
- maldusiecle 11y agoImagine you're figuring out the chance that you'll die this year. Let's say you're 30--probably a common age on HN. There's a 10% chance that you're in the last 10% of your life. Therefore, there's a 10% chance that you'll die in the next three years. If you sold life insurance using those kinds of numbers, you'd have some woes. If you can't use probability meaningfully, it's better not to use it at all; it obfuscates.
- Houshalter 11y agoActually if you don't have any other information about life expectancy, that's a perfectly reasonable prior distribution. We have much more data on life expectancy, and so can give much more accurate probability distributions. But if you didn't have that, the uninformed prior is the best you can do. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prior_probability#Uninformative_priors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prior_probability#Uninformativ... J. Richard Gott famously invented this method to estimate the lifespan of the berlin wall, and predicted a 75% chance that it wouldn't be there by 1993. Also relevant is this article, Risk-Free Bonds Aren't: http://lesswrong.com/lw/hy/riskfree_bonds_arent/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/hy/riskfree_bonds_arent/ >A list of major governments in 1900 would probably put the Ottoman Empire or Austria-Hungary well ahead of the relatively young United States. Citing the good track record of the US alone, and not all governments of equal apparent stability at the start of the same time period, is purest survivorship bias. >But even if you don't share those particular assumptions, do you expect the United States to still be around in 300 years? If not, do you know exactly when it will go bust? Then why isn't the risk of losing your capital on a 30-year Treasury bond at least, say, 10%?
- slg 11y agoBy that logic everything has a 10% chance of ending in the next (history length / 10) period. The year has a greater than 10% chance of ending in the next 2 days. Apple has a greater than 10% chance of closing up shop in the next 5 years. There is a 10% chance that Y Combinator won't exist in a year. It is a prediction based on assumptions about statistics and takes nothing else into consideration.
- rholland 11y agoThis is an interesting mathematical analysis but I am not sure how predictive it really is. It implies that the longer a country has survived, the more likely it is to continue surviving (because 10% of a larger number is a larger number.) This does not hold true for some things, like people. The odds of a 100-year-old person dying before reaching age 110 are more than 10%, and the odds of a 10-year-old person dying before reaching age 11 are less than 10%. This is due to age-dependent-factors such as shortened telomeres and accumulated structural damage. It is possible that countries similarly have age-dependent factors which affect the odds of survival, either positively or negatively. I am not a statistician; I could be completely wrong. Apparently this is a whole debate: http://www.wikiwand.com/en/Doomsday_argument http://www.wikiwand.com/en/Doomsday_argument
- junto 11y agoWith regards to your comments about assumed stability, I believe you are right. The slow attrition of our civil rights and the strengthening of the surveillance state is not unlike the process of smoking cigarettes. In the beginning it seems like fun. Everyone is doing it. People warn you that it's dangerous, but you don't feel bad, and in fact you feel kind of cool. Some years down the line and you start to develop a bit of a nasty hacky cough. You brush it off, but in the back of your head you think it might be connected to your smoking habit. Then one day you feel a lump. You don't feel well, and after a bit of procrastination, you go and see the doctor. You find out you have cancer, and it's terminal. All of a sudden you're dead. How did that happen? You feel like an idiot. You knew smoking was going to kill you, but you did it anyway. Slow attrition is the worst for the human psyche. We just can't get out heads around it.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoWe're not on our first government per se in the US. When you look at basic, constitutional law & the ... mores of how elections work, there's generally a "revolution" about every fifty-eighty years. I'd call the last one at around 1965-1968. We're much closer to the British model - we consider the law actually independent of the government proper. The government depends on law, but there's a quite specific set of interfaces for government to change law. This model is not only surviving but thriving, around the world. I don't know how any modern state, post-WWII, survives without a security apparatus. Perhaps it not be the one we have now, but there will be one, should a government failure happen. It takes very little for the government security apparatus to encourage ratting out dissidents as was done in the Soviet Bloc, effectively drafting every citizen as part of the security apparatus. So the present size of such a thing, pre-collapse may not have anything to do with what it looks like post-collapse. But so far, the basic framework has survived ( knock wood ). There are disturbing parallels with the period leading up to the failure of the Whig Party in American history. But there were self-destruct mechanisms built into things then that aren't apparent now - I can't imagine receiving news of a whopper the size of the Dred Scott Decision today. But perhaps my imagination fails.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]