3 ms·
> our country is becoming a dictatorship. Our country will never become a dictatorship, and our country is already a dictatorship. To be more precise it is an
by rdtsc 11y ago
> our country is becoming a dictatorship.
Our country will never become a dictatorship, and our country is already a dictatorship. To be more precise it is an oligarchy or what was that word... plutocracy? Anyone has a link to that paper?
It is basically ruled by the very few powerful interests.
There are multiple methods of how it is done:
One of the most effective is regulatory capture -- look at heads of FCC, FDA, USDA, Military and corresponding industries: communications, pharma, military industrial complex companies. There is a giant revolving door between them.
Senators and legislature in general (state and federal) can be easily bought as well.
Judicial can be subverted as well. This happens easier on the state level were judges are elected. I found "Hot Coffee" movie pretty interesting and accessible in understanding how the process works: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1445203/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1445203/
Election campaigns are basically a big theater where future political favors are sold for campaign funds.
And finally the PR involved in polarizing the population and manipulating their opinions. On paper the country will never be a dictatorship so this just means spending extra on manipulating public opinion. Bush did a good job mobilizing Evangelical voters. Obama capitalized on liberal votes and sold a story of hope, change, plus added the racial card in there as well. It really was a very well run campaign, not unlike what Coke or Pepsi would have. This is not just a random internet person talking, AdAge -- one of the main marketing interest groups gave Obama an award in 2008
http://adage.com/article/moy-2008/obama-wins-ad-age-s-marketer-year/131810/ http://adage.com/article/moy-2008/obama-wins-ad-age-s-market... for the best marketing campaign. Other usual winners are Coke, Nike, Apple.
The other thing that helps out is that various segments of the population, which would benefit from having a unified voice and position, are divided. It happens naturally in society, but it is of course helped a bit by media: Fox News vs liberal news etc. The division lines are multiple: conservative vs liberal; racial: Whites, Blacks, Hispanics, immigrants; regional: North, South, East vs West; by religion: non-religious, vs Christians vs whatever. It is a bit like the sports fans, the hate the other fans, but in fact they are closer to the other fans in terms of interests, income status, and general life outlook, than they are they with the players they are rooting for, who could be all driving sports cars, and hang out in exclusive expensive downtown bars together.
So minus some PR juggling and the need for some extra rhetoric about "Freedom, democracy, and exceptionalism, mixed with a bit of God and manifest destiny" you are not too far off treating the country like a well run dictatorship.
- fweespeech 11y ago> Our country will never become a dictatorship, and our country is already a dictatorship. To be more precise it is an oligarchy or what was that word... plutocracy? Anyone has a link to that paper? http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746 http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746 1) Oligarchies are not dictatorships. 2) The US was founded as an oligarchy and has been a relatively stable one. This being the case, the OP's point still stands.
- rdtsc 11y ago> 1) Oligarchies are not dictatorships. Good enough for a general heuristic. On paper we are Constitutional Republic and not a Democracy either. But it depends on the level of conversation. Most people on the street would not know Constitutional Republic vs a Democracy even if it hit them on the nose. > 2) The US was founded as an oligarchy and has been a relatively stable one. This being the case, the OP's point still stands. Note: I didn't say a dictatorship would be unstable or everyone would have a bad time. There are and have been lot of dictatorships people support(ed) and didn't rebel against in order to turn them into democracies. The bottom line is people don't have the representative power they think they have. And other, most concentrated power centers make decisions for them. Whether it is one person or 20 large companies doesn't matter much. I can't quite be one person so on paper it will never be dictatorship, just like on paper very few countries identify as "The United Dictatorship of <blah>". Even North Korea, is a "Democratic Republic" on paper. That doesn't mean it is one in reality.
- fweespeech 11y ago> The bottom line is people don't have the representative power they think they have. And other, most concentrated power centers make decisions for them. The sheer volume of people who think the two parties are the same and/or their voting is pointless would disagree with you. > Whether it is one person or 20 large companies doesn't matter much. I can't quite be one person so on paper it will never be dictatorship A large number of opposing poles on a spectrum are involved, it isn't just "20 companies". This competition allows it to function in a reasonable stable manner that appears similar to a Republic as everyone with the power to change the status quo is represented roughly equal to their ability to do so. The simple truth is revolution requires it to be backed by people with resources.