3 ms·
Types are irrelevant to this discussion (the fact that Haskell is typed is a historical accident; the important factor is that it is lazy), and almost everythin
by mcguire 11y ago
Types are irrelevant to this discussion (the fact that Haskell is typed is a historical accident; the important factor is that it is lazy), and almost everything is useless when it comes to reasoning about large and complex dynamic systems. Except breaking them into smaller, simpler systems.
- willtim 11y agoI'm curious about your comment about Types. Types are an important part of Haskell and Haskell was largely based on Miranda. What makes you believe they were an accident? There are more research papers about type system implementations and extensions regarding Haskell, than there are about laziness.
- mcguire 11y agoDon't get me wrong, types are an important part of Haskell. They're probably a significant chunk of the reason Haskell exists, since that is what separates the ML family from Lisps (again, more-or-less). Types are, however, irrelevant to Haskell's relationship to category theory, which is more-or-less the topic under discussion. Haskell needs monads in order to do stateful things like IO, that are necessary for a programming language but a thorn in the side of lazy languages which don't have an easily defined execution order. Category theory's importance to Haskell and vice-versa have nothing to do with Haskell's type system and much more to do with the fact that it is a lazy functional programming language. In fact, one of the weaknesses of Haskell's type system is that it can't enforce the "monad laws" when you give an implementation of the monad typeclass.