3 ms·
> Surveillance sliding into dictatorship is one of the most common ways that democracies fall. What? Give me one example where surveillance was the _reason_ an
by golergka 11y ago
> Surveillance sliding into dictatorship is one of the most common ways that democracies fall.
What? Give me one example where surveillance was the _reason_ and main tool for ascending dictator.
- distracted_boy 11y agoIn Nazi Germany the Stasi was quite effective in monitoring people, suppressing the people and keeping them in constant fear. Maybe not the main tool for Hitler to reach his position as Fürer but it was certainly one of the main tools to keep him in power.
- hiram112 11y agoThe Stasi was East Germany's post WWII security apparatus. You're confusing it with the Gestapo. I understand and agree with what you were probably trying to say ;)
- golergka 11y agoI hope you don't get offended if I say that when you attribute Stasi to Nazis, you don't show a depth of historical knowledge required to blindly trust you on your analysis on these issues. Yes, every regime is trying to get information about who's trying to destroy it. But (1) it's not a tool to get to power as much as a tool to hold to power, and (2) it's not inherently evil: if you have some regime that you actually like and don't want to see violently overthrown, you would support such measures, implemented in a reasonable way (!), too.
- hiram112 11y agoI don't think most arguments against surveillance are necessarily implying that it is the reason that dictators rise, but instead it is one of many tools used to allow it to happen. Furthermore, the fact that billions of people are voluntarily using social media, all stored on private company's cloud servers, along with ML, massive computing increases gives those who'd use surveillance for power grabs exponentially more power than the Stasi, KGB, Hoover's FBI, etc. could have ever dreamed of.
- golergka 11y ago> I don't think most arguments against surveillance are necessarily implying that it is the reason that dictators rise, but instead it is one of many tools used to allow it to happen. But that's what the quote from the post is claiming. > Furthermore, the fact that billions of people are voluntarily using social media, all stored on private company's cloud servers, along with ML, massive computing increases gives those who'd use surveillance for power grabs exponentially more power than the Stasi, KGB, Hoover's FBI, etc. could have ever dreamed of. No, Hoover wouldn't. When you compare Hoover's era to today, compare how easier it is to track paper letters and phone calls than email and skype, and more importantly, how much more of emails and skype calls do we have now than then. The only thing that have gotten easier is to bulk process them, yes. But if you actually want to tap communications of certain individuals for some legitimate reasons (and I think we all can agree that in the most corrupt and awful country, there are some situations where these legitimate reasons exist), you would need much more man-hours and effort to do that.
- ksdale 11y agoMany dictatorships have relied on people turning in their neighbors for being opponents of the regime. I think that people turning in their neighbors based on things they've seen them do/say is a pretty good approximation of surveillance. I would go so far as to argue that many a dictatorship would have been far less scary (and effective) if people weren't worried that their neighbors would turn them in.
- golergka 11y ago> Many dictatorships have relied on people turning in their neighbors for being opponents of the regime. I think that people turning in their neighbors based on things they've seen them do/say is a pretty good approximation of surveillance. I would go so far as to argue that many a dictatorship would have been far less scary (and effective) if people weren't worried that their neighbors would turn them in. Given as my family lived and suffered from this kind of dictatorship throughout three consecutive generations, I hope I can explain why I don't think that this is surveillance. You see, when you write to NKVD to say that your neighbor said a joke about Stalin, they don't actually check if what you've said is true. They don't honestly care. The accuracy of your report is completely irrelevant to the system, and even further — if these reports were actually checked, the system wouldn't be as effective, because this would mean that the system actually had rules. Instead, this report system was based on complete paranoia and random violence. Random violence, not based on any actual rules, but only pretending to be, is much more effective in putting people in a state of learned helplessness and upholding the regime — while (in the example of 30s Soviet Union) killing almost the whole elite several times over. This has nothing to do with surveillance.
- jccc 11y agoI don't believe he's implying causation, though the word choice might carelessly suggest it. He means canary in the coal mine.
- _yosefk 11y agoI think Stalin gained influence in part by "having the goods" on a lot of people, but I don't have a citation on that. This didn't happen in a democracy to begin with, however, there was much more open discussion and dissent within the ruling party before Stalin than after. (I don't have a firm opinion on what modern surveillance will do politically over time, just answering your specific question.)
- golergka 11y agoI've never seen anything about "having the goods" being really important in this process, and would really like to see a citation about it.
- walid 11y agoNo the comment is not about dictators, it is about democracies falling. Update: take for example google/twitter/facebook and how they have a lot of control over what we do online. Because they have that info they can influence our lives. Facebook's mood experiment is a recent example. Also if a picture of an election candidate is shared a lot, that candidate gets more votes by causation. Google/twitter/facebook don't have a political agenda behind their abilities and people are concerned about their influence. It makes more sense to be concerned about politically controlled agencies.
- golergka 11y agoCompare facebook's live feed to TV programming in the era when you only had about 4-6 channels in your box, and your whole social circle was watching them — which applies much more peer pressure to consume this data channel than you have today to continue reading your facebook/twitter feed. Please, stop analyzing things as being "good" or "bad". By any reasonable person's standards, the whole today's world is just awful. It's not usable. Use "worse" and "better" instead: when we compare things to one another, only then can we get somewhere.
- walid 11y agoI just remembered. Mubarak the ex-dictator of Egypt became a dictator because of the surveillance apparatus created by his predecessor Jamal Abdul Nasser.