3 ms·
My understanding is that it 'looks for signs', if it expects them to be there. Obviously, it has to look at the stoplight to see what color it is. But it won't
by ocdtrekkie 11y ago
My understanding is that it 'looks for signs', if it expects them to be there. Obviously, it has to look at the stoplight to see what color it is. But it won't look at arbitrary space for a stoplight it isn't told exists.
Source, by the way: slate.com/articles/technology/technology/2014/10/google_self_driving_car_it_may_never_actually_happen.html
FWIW, a Googler has done a TED talk about having the car recognize police officers holding signs and temporary things like that, more recently, so they may have made strides in solving this problem.
But at it's core, the Self-Driving Car Project seems way too reliant on Google's cloud servers for my taste. I'd love to have a self-driving car, but it needs to be self-driving, not Google-driving.
- Someone 11y agoGive it ten years, and that traffic light problem may solve itself. I would not surprise me if we would eventually see every traffic light broadcast its GPS location, cycle pattern, and phase, either using radio or by modulating their light source. That still is risky (hackers could hack the logic in a traffic light), but less risky than relying on one central authority to know what he whole world looks like. Also, I don't think it is a good idea, but chances are police officers will have ways to stop self-driving car without giving visual signs.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoIt would definitely be useful for traffic lights to be beacons, but I think you might underestimate the government time scale for renovating and modernizing our infrastructure on a national scale.
- deftnerd 11y agoThat's a clever solution. Many lights have moved over to arrays of colored LEDs. The bulbs themselves could transmit data, similar to LiFi, to cars. The LED arrays could also have a LiFi receiver. To prevent hacking, the data transmitted by the traffic lights could be digitally signed using the public key of the jurisdiction. If 2 way communications is required, vehicles could sign their data with a vehicle key too. Something like this would be a good way to securely allow lights to change their behavior when emergency vehicles or mass transit vehicles approach, broadcast road warnings to all vehicles, broadcast amber alerts. It could also receive reports from vehicles on average speed in road segments, reports of icy conditions (from vehicle traction feedback), reports of potholes or other maintenance issues, etc.