26 ms·
Trying to define personhood using any sort of scientific analysis is a dangerous road that was/is used to justify horrific acts of racism, violence, and subjuga
by Spivak 11y ago
Trying to define personhood using any sort of scientific analysis is a dangerous road that was/is used to justify horrific acts of racism, violence, and subjugation, including Social Darwinism in the early 1900s, and the eugenics movement that followed.
I can think of no objective testable definition of person which is both meaningful (i.e. non-trivial) and not horrific for corner cases or those that would be excluded.
I know this wasn't your intention because you're using it to grant personhood to more entities but the implications aren't great regardless.
- oniMaker 11y agoNo, this is the wrong approach. The object is not to define personhood through some objective set of criteria which can then be used to justify evil; it's to use our observations about the world to arrive at a broader and more humane outlook. The argument itself is wrong as well. If some method X is used for evil, it does not mean X is intrinsically evil. This is essentially the same flawed argument that's used against many areas of science.