4 ms·
The "lane lines optional" nature of snowstorms definitely is going to require a leap of logic I don't soon expect self-driving cars to understand. Will the car
by ocdtrekkie 11y ago
The "lane lines optional" nature of snowstorms definitely is going to require a leap of logic I don't soon expect self-driving cars to understand.
Will the car be able to measure the depth of snow on the road? And find the most driveable part of the road? The high reflectivity of snow probably isn't a good ally for this use case.
- peregrine 11y agoNot to mention the composition or what might be below the snow. Snow and ice are by far the hardest conditions for anyone driving. I have no doubt a computer can figure it out and be better eventually, until then it will be interesting.
- maxerickson 11y agoElectronic stability control is required by regulation in several jurisdictions (US, Canada, EU now or soon). From that it can be inferred that computers are better at some aspects of it already.
- dsfyu404ed 11y agoI don't know what you think ESP is but it's purely a "damage control" type of driver aid and is only a layer of programming on top of ABS. ESP just modulates brakes to keep you from going sideways. It's basically automated cutting brakes paired with traction control and ABS. All ESP does is utilize the car's existing technology to better do what the driver wants. It pretty much only comes into affect when the driver cranks the wheel hard enough to use up all available traction. It keeps the vehicle in an understeer condition and uses all available traction to try and steer in the desired direction (by acting like cutting brakes). The point of this is so that the "AWD means I don't actually need to know what I'm doing people" are prevented from sideways (oversteer) because understeer is a lot easier for a novice to recover from and if he/she hits a pole he/she hits it head on utilizing the part of the car that's good at crashing "softly" The traction control part of ESP is somewhat irrelevant. If the used is trying to give it throttle while the ESP code is doing it's thing and the ESP code is telling the traction control code to override the user then the user should just pull the fuse because you do better doughnuts that way...
- maxerickson 11y agoI understand what it is. It works because it can accurately estimate the available traction. A lot of the problems drivers have in slippery conditions boil down to not correctly estimating available traction.
- shkkmo 11y ago> Not to mention the composition or what might be below the snow. I don't feel like this is particularly harder than any of the other problems self-driving cars face. To achieve performance on par with human drivers simple need to do a couple of things (which are what I do when driving in snowy/icey conditions): 1) Categorize current/recent road appearance into groups. 2) Do tiny periodic break checks on each relevant group to determine the traction available in that group. 3) Trigger a new set break checks when conditions change (e.g. exterior temp changes, precipitation changes, traffic density changes or road-type changes such as exit ramp or bridge) This road surface analysis combined with a bit of traffic analysis should also allow you to determine 'emergent lanes' in snowy conditions.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Will the car be able to measure the depth of snow on the road? And find the most driveable part of the road? The high reflectivity of snow probably isn't a good ally for this use case. Use a thermal camera to find the road? Or perhaps contrast, as the parts of the road with less slow should have roadway peek through. To determine how much snow you're dealing with, you detect wheel slip, which can assist in determining depth.
- knz 11y agoOnce cars have better connectivity it may be easier. Assuming busy traffic you could follow the average track of the last n cars etc.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoIt's hard to suggest how this would be handled on a all-encompassing scale. I'm sure Google would like to simply track every car on the road, but between multiple brands of cars and software, and valid privacy concerns, this isn't a great solution. Also, you'd need to validate that data carefully. You wouldn't want false submissions to end up strongly recommend cars drive off a cliff.
- scarlson 11y agoSo nationalize it? It's not like big brother isn't already tracking traffic trends. Why shouldn't the Dept of Transportation be in charge of directing automated traffic?
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoThere's ups and downs to that. Companies like Google would argue that their systems are too integrated to their business to be nationalized. (Unless we just nationalize Google. It's enough of a monopoly now........) The biggest issue would be that this is still a rapidly developing field, and the one thing government is not good at is rapidly evolving technology. But fundamentally, we will need something controlled by an agency or government, or at least a nonprofit organization of some sort. A single corporation can't control our nation's transportation infrastructure.
- jonknee 11y agoHumans haven't been able to figure it out either (so many Winter accidents). At least the automated car will drive slowly and at a safe following distance.
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoInterestingly, driver aids have been implicated in causing more severe winter accidents, eg. this [1] 100-car pile-up in Sweden a few years back. Basically, people don't understand that the ESP lamp flashing means "slow down or you will probably crash". Drive an old, RWD, no electronics car and you'll be more aware of dangerous conditions. 100% non-overridable self-driving cars may someday fix this, but things will probably get worse before they get better. Humans being humans, they will think the car is overly cautious most of the time, and put it in manual because they're running 5 mins late. The more interesting question about the automated car is "can it do a Scandinavian flick"? They should come with a dedicated button for that. [1] http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-21035634 http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-21035634
- deathanatos 11y ago> driver aids have been implicated in causing more severe winter accidents, eg. this [1] 100-car pile-up in Sweden a few years back. The linked article, AFAICT, doesn't implicate driver aids in the accident, at all. (It's a rather short article, and the video doesn't mention anything about driver aids either.) Am I missing something?
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoI couldn't find anything in English, but local media had discussions along these lines at the time, with incident responders blaming ESP systems. They had ambulances with flashing lights being hit by new cars coming to the scene of the accident, i.e. it didn't happen within just a few seconds; in this case it's apparent that drivers were oblivious to just how bad the conditions were. I'm not saying ESP is a bad thing, mind you. The technical system works well and has reduced accidents overall, this is proven in several studies. There's been a few faulty ESP systems causing accidents, e.g. the Audi A3 and the Alfa Romeo Spider around '05 (fixed in recalls), but overall it's a success. But the more abstractions you put between the car and the driver, the more your run the risk of drivers ignoring, or not being aware of, bad conditions. Educating users about proper operation of any system is notoriously difficult.
- jgroszko 11y agoIt seems like the high reflectivity of snow would help in case of following the tracks of the previous car, where I'd guess the car's tracks are a little bit less reflective than the fresh untouched snow on the rest of the road?