7 ms·
Let's be honest, humans are pretty bad at driving in snow too. Sadly, I feel like people won't accept self driving cars until they can drive in the snow as wel
by jedberg 11y ago
Let's be honest, humans are pretty bad at driving in snow too.
Sadly, I feel like people won't accept self driving cars until they can drive in the snow as well as in dry, clear conditions, which won't happen for a long time, if ever.
Honestly it's a bit silly that self driving cars have to do better than humans to be trusted -- as long as they are doing as well as us, mathematically, we should want them.
Maybe the insurance companies, which are mathematically inclined, will end up fixing this by providing lower rates for self driving cars, even in snowy climates.
- dubcanada 11y agoThe problem is with humans it's fairly clear most of the time who made the error. It's either human 1 or human 2 99% of the time. With self driving cars it becomes software 1 or software 2... And at that point it's extremely difficult where to point the blame.
- oldmanjay 11y agodo you care to fill in the logic between your start and end? I don't really follow the leap. It seems the tools we use to determine fault now, frail though they may be, are equally sufficient no matter which bundles of electrical fields are controlling things.
- Bjartr 11y agoOn the flip side, with software you have logs. It's much more clear what actually happened and when, who acted first etc.
- dmm 11y ago(With the enormous safety benefits of self-driving cars) Maybe it won't be worth it to assign blame? It's happened before with no-fault insurance.
- runamok 11y agoWhy would it be harder? Most likely there will be laws to disclose telemetry, video, etc. in the event of an accident. Most likely an audit trail of what the sensor inputs were and what the decision made was, etc. More likely there will just be no-fault where both parties pay unless there is a spate of accidents that point to software/hardware issues.
- ohitsdom 11y agoI was recently wondering how the insurance industry will respond to self-driving cars. When self-driving vehicles are a small percentage of the market, it helps reduce their claims. When the entire grid is self-driving, the industry will be much smaller. We're probably at least 40 years away from that, but it still should happen someday.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThe insurance industry would disappear. If you own and manage your own self-driving vehicle fleet, you're going to self-insure. https://usinsuranceagents.com/answers/3251/what-is-self-insured-car-insurance https://usinsuranceagents.com/answers/3251/what-is-self-insu...
- fweespeech 11y agoMany people, particularly in rural areas, are still going to want private cars. They will get insurance. Leasing capacity with little delay will only work in regions with dense population.
- icebraining 11y agoWhy do they need insurance? Poorly maintained cars will probably just refuse to go, so any flaws will be either deliberate tampering (which most insurances already don't cover, AFAIK) or the fault of the manufacturer.
- fweespeech 11y agoNo system is fault proof and I doubt we will ever surrender the ability to manually override the system.
- icebraining 11y agoMaybe, but will any company be willing to insure the case when the user deliberately drives despite the car telling them not to?
- theklub 11y agoI guess you should want them, if you want to continue moving towards total loss of freedom and privacy.
- freehunter 11y agoOr, you know, if you want to stay alive, since driving is by far one of the most dangerous things we do every day.
- theklub 11y agoYou want to live in a bubble, good for you. Give me freedom or give me death. I'd bet most of the people who are hard for these cars don't even own them, they just don't want to deal with taxi drivers anymore.
- magicalist 11y ago> You want to live in a bubble, good for you. Give me freedom or give me death. You can still walk. They don't allow your rocket car on public roads today, so obviously there's some level of bubble you're willing to accept.
- VLM 11y agoI pulled the CDC stats and it looks like eating and lack-of-exercise kill about 50x as many people as vehicle accidents. Also generic falls are only 4K behind vehicle accidents. Somehow poisoning beat vehicle accidents by 4K, I'm not sure how, maybe counting prescription drug interactions and allergies? http://www.worldlifeexpectancy.com/usa-cause-of-death-by-age-and-gender http://www.worldlifeexpectancy.com/usa-cause-of-death-by-age... It would appear the most dangerous daily activity is eating and not exercising. So your kitchen and living room couch are by far the most dangerous things in your life. Deep in the decimal points come poisoning, falling, and driving, all roughly the same odds. Someone else killing you is about half the odds of those three. Drowning is about a tenth the odds of driving although most adult drowning is probably outside the house and most people don't swim every day (although it is excellent exercise). On average you're about a fifth as likely to die of HIV than driving so the bedroom is probably safer than the drivers seat, on a very long term average, although HIV clusters extremely strongly into certain demographics, so bedrooms are basically safe for almost all of us and a death sentence for certain demographics. In summary, there are some daily household activities that are safer than driving, such as having recreational sex, but your kitchen and living room couch are maybe a hundred times more likely to kill you than driving, and its about equal odds for falls, poisoning, and driving. The odds are about 49 in 50 that you're not going to die in a car accident. (edited to add this is worrisome WRT death rates if people sit in self driving cars and stuff themselves with junk food while watching TV or something... the overall death rate might very well go up, even if vehicular deaths supernaturally dropped to zero)
- twoodfin 11y agoLet's be honest, humans are pretty bad at driving in snow too. Sure, but most human drivers can call upon a wealth of experience both with driving and interacting with the physical world in general. They have an incredibly rich mental model, allowing for adaptations that would be risky or impossible to program into an autonomous driver. For example, when lane lines are missing or obscured, human drivers will often follow the car in front of them... unless they observe erratic behavior that might indicate the driver ahead has lost control. What's "erratic behavior" is a judgement I wouldn't expect near-future software to be particularly good at. Of course, there are areas like reaction time and feedback-based control where autonomous drivers will always be vastly superior to human ones. Which is why it seems to me that the safest option in the medium term is likely to be (as it is today) an increasingly software-assisted human driver. This is the primary reason I'm down on the chances for wide adoption of fully (or mostly) autonomous drivers in the next 5-10 years: Human + computer will be a safer, more reliable alternative. The active participation of the human will fall off over time, but I think it will be a much flatter curve than many enthusiasts expect.
- jerf 11y ago"Human + computer will be a safer, more reliable alternative." Unfortunately, there's a cliff where if you aren't stimulating the human enough, they stop paying attention. They can't help it. Their neural architecture is fundamentally structured to do that and merely trying not to isn't going to cut it. We can't have automated cars that 98% drive autonomously but beep when they need help, right now. This could work if the car can reliably predict when it is going to need help in 10+ seconds, but I'm not sure that's practical. (Which I phrase that way on purpose... maybe it is. I'm just not sure. Would certainly take a lot of work and some very conservative automated driving.)
- seanp2k2 11y agoTo be able to know that it's doing something wrong or mis-reading things would require some deeper understanding of what it's doing (or at least a confidence score or similar). This is why it'd likely be important for s human to be overseeing it 100% of the time, to step in and swiftly make a manual override when the autonomy doesn't realize it's about to do something stupid.
- serge2k 11y ago> Sadly, I feel like people won't accept self driving cars until they can drive in the snow as well as in dry, clear conditions, which won't happen for a long time, if ever. Well yeah, I want to be able to drive my car year round. If it doesn't work in the snow it's useless for months for a large portion of the country. Even here in Seattle the rain is a big challenge.