3 ms·
This is very similar to a problem in linguistics (and in some ways "is" a linguistics problem). You can define what an acorn is, and you can define a tree, but
by jedberg 11y ago
This is very similar to a problem in linguistics (and in some ways "is" a linguistics problem).
You can define what an acorn is, and you can define a tree, but when does an acorn become a tree? Same with baldness. Everyone can identify a bald person and likewise someone who isn't bald, but when do you go from not bald to bald? This incidentally is part of the fundamental debate about abortion (when does a fetus become a child?).
And it is the same here -- we can define a human and "not human" but we're having trouble defining exactly when it goes from one to the next.
- yarou 11y agoI'm not a big fan of defining objects by their opposites. Derrida argues exactly this in Deconstruction, but it's fairly useless in deriving meaning. I believe Frege had it right by observing that there is a sense and reference to each and every word or concept. It's not sufficient enough to derive meaning from referential labels; context always matters more.
- pc2g4d 11y agoI saw the linguistics connection as being that distinguishing one genus/species from another is a very similar problem to distinguishing one language/dialect from another. In both cases the population of organisms or of language users doesn't break apart into disjoint subsets naturally---nobody has a label within them saying "homo sapiens" or "Farsi speaker". These distinctions are artificially imposed and ultimately arbitrary.