3 ms·
> A mathematical proof applies to all cases, not just one. Gödel's result addressed Russell's project, but it applies universally, as do all valid mathematical
by geofft 11y ago
> A mathematical proof applies to all cases, not just one. Gödel's result addressed Russell's project, but it applies universally, as do all valid mathematical results.
What? I have no idea what you mean by "applies universally" and "all valid mathematical results."
A straightforward reading of that sentence implies that Pythagoras' Theorem is not a "valid mathematical result" because it applies only to right triangles. That can't be what you're saying, is it?
I am acknowledging that Gödel's second theorem states that any mathematical system that attempts to prove itself is doomed to failure. I am also stating that Russell's project involved a mathematical system that attempts to prove itself. Therefore, Gödel's second theorem applies to Russell's project, but it does not necessarily say anything else about other projects.
> Many mathematicians regard Gödel's result as the most important mathematical finding of the 20th century.
So what? This is argumentum ad populum. How important the mathematical finding is is irrelevant to whether it matters to the discussion at hand.
> This is false. If the Halting problem is insoluble, it is also insoluble to a human
OK, so do you believe that modern mathematics is invalid because Russell's project failed?