4 ms·
The trouble with Skylon is that all of these things you mention make it more ambitious, but they don't really make it more useful. The main advantage Skylon wo
by mikeash 11y ago
The trouble with Skylon is that all of these things you mention make it more ambitious, but they don't really make it more useful.
The main advantage Skylon would have over the Falcon 9 is the fact that the Falcon 9 is not fully reusable because they don't and can't recover the second stage, while the entire Skylon is recovered.
That's significant, of course. The second stage makes up about 25% the cost of the rocket, so that places a ceiling of about 75% on how much Falcon 9 reusability can save..
But then, starting from where the Falcon 9 is now, building a new rocket that can also recover the second stage doesn't seem too difficult. It's a big challenge, to be sure, but relative to Skylon it's not too bad.
Skylon is certainly much more ambitious in terms of how it works, but it doesn't seem to be very ambitious in terms of what it can do, which is not a promising combination.
- Thorondor 11y agoSkylon does have the advantage of burning atmospheric oxygen at low altitudes, meaning it would have a significantly higher payload fraction than the Falcon 9.
- mikeash 11y agoIt's somewhat higher, but not dramatically so. Skylon is projected to be 325 tons loaded with a LEO payload of 15 tons, Falcon 9 Full Thrust a.k.a. Falcon 9 1.2 is 541 tons loaded with a LEO payload of 13-17 tons depending on who you believe. And that's comparing paper hardware with flying hardware. Spacecraft tend to get heavier as they go from paper to reality. Plus, payload fraction is another thing like SSTO, horizontal takeoff, novel heat shields, and all the rest that are cool but just don't matter except for how they affect the end result. All that matters in the end is how much you can launch, and how much it costs.
- gozur88 11y ago>And that's comparing paper hardware with flying hardware. Spacecraft tend to get heavier as they go from paper to reality. That's the critical point. Skylon is still vaporware, and they've really assumed the best case in published numbers.
- creshal 11y agoAccording to specs it'll reach 1600 m/s on atmospheric oxygen. So, afterwards, it needs another 8000 m/s Δv on rocket engines to reach LEO. Skylon is a neat trick, but it's not magical.