2 ms·
That was indeed the state of the art in Galileo's time. Heliocentrism wasn't necessarily more elegant, because it left open problems such as why people don't fl
by analog31 11y ago
That was indeed the state of the art in Galileo's time. Heliocentrism wasn't necessarily more elegant, because it left open problems such as why people don't fly off the earth, and why the oceans don't slosh around uncontrollably. From what I've read, the Church was prepared to accept the model of Tycho Brahe, in which the sun goes around the earth, and the planets around the sun, which is yet another equivalent view within that conception of reality.
Newton gave us a couple of things. First, as you say, he gave us a model of gravity. Secondly, he gave us the framework within which to test whether the earth is rotating or not, e.g., through observations of things like Foucault's pendulum, and the Coriolis force.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI actually have some sources from my yesterday's discussion handy: http://qr.ae/R4iSbs http://qr.ae/R4iSbs http://lesswrong.com/lw/lq6/the_galileo_affair_who_was_on_the_side_of/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/lq6/the_galileo_affair_who_was_on_th... http://lesswrong.com/lw/lq6/the_galileo_affair_who_was_on_the_side_of/bz9v http://lesswrong.com/lw/lq6/the_galileo_affair_who_was_on_th... They paint a completely different picture of Galileo than the one taught in schools. TL;DR: Galileo was onto the right idea, but for totally wrong reasons. His model was worse than existing ones and unsupported by available empirical data - therefore it was justly rejected by contemporary scientific community. And the issue with Church was apparently about Galileo being a dick to the Pope.