4 ms·
Here's the problem with this: the planets' orbits aren't circles. And scientists had good enough measurements, that they knew circular orbits didn't match the
by mcphage 11y ago
Here's the problem with this: the planets' orbits aren't circles. And scientists had good enough measurements, that they knew circular orbits didn't match the observed behavior. So neither of those models are very good. It wasn't until people figured out that orbits are ellipses instead of circles, that we actually had a model that was simpler and more accurate than the cycles-and-epicycles of geocentrism.
- terravion 11y agoExactly this. Everyone says oh, it is so much easier to calculate with circles around the sun--this only true if you want wrong answers to the position of the planets. So wrong that you can see it with the naked eye. Nobody believed Copernicus because his model was not predictive--this gets left out when we want to tell stories about Medieval anti-scientific bias. When Kepler came along and introduces an elliptical heliocentric model with the equal areas law, scientifically minded people switch to the heliocentric view. However, the math for this is really hard. We use elliptical curves in cryto today. You can calculate the position of a planet with Ptolemy's model on an abacus with nothing more complex than division.
- jacobolus 11y agoNote that an elliptic curve is not at all the same as an ellipse. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elliptic_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elliptic_curve
- vilmosi 11y agoI don't think that's a problem at all. The eccentricities are so small, you wouldn't even notice it.