5 ms·
Starving spammers of IPs is not really a solution to spam anyway. Reforming smtp is. And it is long long long overdue... What I don't understand is that pretty
by cm2187 11y ago
Starving spammers of IPs is not really a solution to spam anyway. Reforming smtp is. And it is long long long overdue...
What I don't understand is that pretty much everyone has an incentive to eliminate spam. ISPs to reduce traffic, emails providers to produce a better service and spend less time dealing with spam. Users for obvious reasons. Only the NSA enjoys the current unencrypted status quo. Why doesn't it happen? Why are we stuck with a 30y protocol?
- mahouse 11y agoWhat do you suggest as a solution?
- cm2187 11y agoA new smtp protocol with: - mandatory encryption, mandatory validation of certificates - certainty on the sender (effectively a mandatory hardfail spf) - ideally decoupling the email address from the provider running the mail server (users shouldn't be prisonners of a gmail or a yahoo) [edit] also a system of extended validation for signatures like for ssl certificates would be useful. I would end up expecting a nice green logo in my mail client for emails from citibank.com, something cit1bank.com could not achieve. [edit2] also a modern design would require emails to be instantaneous. All these messenger apps would become redundant and we would revert to a common standard.
- mfincham 11y agoI've said it before but I'll say it again: http://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt http://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt Good checklist of things a potential "reformed SMTP" needs to do.
- andreasvc 11y agoThat's quite the low effort response. You could've at least mentioned a point or two that applies to this situation. The list you linked to is not a check list, it only lists ways to shoot ideas down. Although I don't necessarily disagree with the skepticism in this case, consider for a second that a very similar list could have been written up until right before the Wright brothers took off with their plane, supposedly proving manned flight impossible.
- geofft 11y agoManned flight was a new technology. The proposal to build a new SMTP with [...] requires abandoning SMTP as it is now and convincing everyone to switch. If the Wright Brothers wanted to eliminate auto accidents by flying, anyone at the time could have told them they were doomed to failure, and history would have proven them right, even though air travel is safer than road travel. That's because getting people to stop using cars isn't simply a matter of inventing an airplane.
- klenwell 11y agoa very similar list could have been written up until right before the Wright brothers took off with their plane, supposedly proving manned flight impossible Someone should write up such a list along with a bot that replies to any post that cites the craphound link linked above. I think it's a valid counterpoint. Nevertheless, whenever someone offers up a cure-all for SMTP, that craphound list is the first thing that comes to mind.
- j42 11y agoProbably because very little innovation happens to any long-standing protocol until it becomes a primary business concern. Almost every business relies on OpenSSL or some equivalent, but how many actually learn enough about SSL to contribute back to the codebase? Not many, because despite the need there's little acclaim or funding to be had pursuing things that won't make direct revenues, regardless of their importance. Protocols like this generally don't get updated until it becomes a matter of necessity -- either by public awareness (we're far from that point) or someone designing the "next big thing" needs an un-implemented feature and contributes.
- cm2187 11y agoOne can argue that spam and phishing IS a business concern. Many of the major data breaches involved a phishing attack. Fixing smtp should be as important if not more than upgrading http 1.1.
- j42 11y agoOh it absolutely is, and I'm on your side. My point though, is that it's always a "secondary" or "tertiary" business concern... a point emboldened by the number and frequency of data breaches -- always followed of course, by the email newsletter follow-up & mea culpa. "We care about the security of your data, we swear. We regret to inform you that ..." Sadly things are not always as they should be, friend...
- geofft 11y agoThe incentives aren't aligned right. Every business will still need SMTP to receive email from outsiders, and through that SMTP will come spam. Even if two businesses decide to switch to a better protocol between them, they're still running SMTP to reach anyone else. And unless you permit sending a single message to both SMTP and better-than-SMTP recipients without any UI awareness, you've built a product that's strictly worse than SMTP for end users. You could add features to email to make a more compelling product, and then kill seamless integration with other SMTP users and still have a better product. (See e.g. Slack. Or Facebook, for personal email.) And then maybe in many many years nobody will want email any more. But that won't be quick.
- cm2187 11y agoThe market is very concentrated. If gmail, yahoo, microsoft and comcast announce that they will gradually increase the spam level on non-"new smtp" traffic, you can bet that adoption rate will stellar. Yes smtp will have to be around for a while but if you treat any legacy mail traffic as suspicious once it becomes <10%, I think it will go away within 3-5 years.
- geofft 11y agoMost of those providers already enforce DMARC between themselves, which provides all the anti-spam benefit you could hope for from a new protocol. (In terms of protocol beauty, it's awful, but in terms of functionality it does what you want.) If Gmail, Yahoo, Microsoft, and Comcast announced that they are making it more likely that outside email (from online stores, from individual Exchange installations, etc.) will be marked as spam when it's not actually spam, people will find new email hosts. Somehow. If they just want to mark traffic as spam when it is, they're already doing that.
- cm2187 11y agoI am not so sure. Senders are more concerned about their emails not appearing as spam in gmail than the other way round. If all it takes is to update their software, I believe they will do.