4 ms·
I really wish people would use log scale for this kind of graph. Trying to study rates of growth on a linear scale is basically impossible during exponential-i
by jacobolus 11y ago
I really wish people would use log scale for this kind of graph.
Trying to study rates of growth on a linear scale is basically impossible during exponential-ish growth periods. All but the rightmost end of the chart gets squished flat along the horizontal axis.
Similarly, charts of e.g. currency exchange rates, stock indices, comparative economic growth between countries, etc. should most of the time be plotted with a log-scaled vertical axis. Otherwise there’s no way to accurately compare slopes in different parts of the chart, which can be deeply misleading.
- kittiepryde 11y agoI think this video was targeted for a casual audience, that may not know what a log graph is.
- jacobolus 11y agoFor log scale charts aimed at the general public, the key is very clear labeling along the axis. I think most viewers can handle it okay; the bigger problem is that charting tools default to linear scale and most chart makers don’t think about it. It’s in some ways too bad that slide rules have been replaced by electronic calculators. I feel like the general public coming out of high school used to have more fluency with logarithms, which until the last generation or two were the basic tool for all calculation in science and engineering.
- joosters 11y agoI thought the lack of log scale was perfect here, he was demonstrating the exponential growth, so why hide it with a log scale?
- Houshalter 11y agoLog scales are extremely misleading. It looks like computing power has only increased a bit since the 1980s, when in fact it has increased orders of magnitude. Especially for a general audience, but even people familiar with log scales, it doesn't give an intuitive feel of the actual numbers.
- jacobolus 11y agoI agree with you that not enough people are familiar with log-scale charts, but that’s a problem with experience, not with “intuition”. Log-scaled charts give perfectly fine “intuitive feeling” for anyone who is used to reading them. Which would include most people if log-scaled charts were more ubiquitous. I am lamenting that they are not, because for many, many purposes they are easier to read and facilitate more useful intra-chart comparisons than linear-scaled charts. In particular, they make the slope of lines meaningful in many cases where linear-scaled charts do not. They also fit much more useful information about relative magnitude and allow us to read a couple significant digits of numbers across a wide range of scales. Any time there is more than 2 orders of magnitude difference among values a chart, a linear scale becomes nearly useless. Reading charts at all is an acquired skill, and takes a lot more practice than you might expect. Just like doing arithmetic with fractions, decimals, or angles of a circle is an acquired skill, or driving a car is an acquired skill. If you study young children or people from non-literate cultures, you’ll see all kinds of difficulty reading linear-scaled charts. Edit: here, I spent a couple minutes making a linear-scaled and a log-scaled chart of the wikipedia $/gigaflops table from elsewhere in this thread, using Matlab. See how much useful information you can get from the linear-scaled chart: http://i.imgur.com/A80Tr6V.png http://i.imgur.com/A80Tr6V.png http://i.imgur.com/xG0mngX.png http://i.imgur.com/xG0mngX.png (On the log-scaled chart, if we penciled in a grid, you could get at least one significant figure out of each data point, despite the data spanning 11 orders of magnitude. On the linear-scaled chart, you get 2 significant figures for a single data point, but there’s no way to make any distinction at all between the rest of the values, which span about 8 orders of magnitude.)
- Houshalter 11y agoIMO neither chart gives an intuitive feel for the data. That nice straight line does nothing to emphasize just how rapidly the price dropped over the last 10 years. That's why I listed a table of the raw numbers instead of a graph. People understand the scale of numbers, and the scale isn't lost by trying to cram it into a chart. The video used a zooming chart, which solves both problems.
- 11y ago