3 ms·
Pretty good read. The amount of interventionism, control and central planning involved in what and where gets spent, how tarrifs, and international agreements
by rdtsc 11y ago
Pretty good read.
The amount of interventionism, control and central planning involved in what and where gets spent, how tarrifs, and international agreements work is staggering. And this was of course written before the massive bailouts during the housing crisis.
There is also a need it seems to constantly protect the political and economic ideology. Cannot simply, for example, institute basic income, that's too socialistic sounding, and it would involved a lot of ideological backpedalling. So to keep it masked, have to first create a threat -- "Terrorism / Communism / Drugs / War", which creates an industry, then shuffle money that way. Then few friends on top pocket some of the money and the rest trickles down as "jobs".
> When asked to identify the largest element of the federal budget, less than 1/4 give the correct answer, military spending
Well maybe it was true in early 90s' But today if you include mandatory (entitlems) or just discretionary spending budget in the pie. Mandatory spending is dominated by medical (medicare etc) and social security. So that part doesn't sound right. Anyone know more?
As a post script, another aspect that is interesting I think, I after reading this, depending on which ideology the reader subscribes to, they will come out with different conclusions. If they are more liberal -- they might say, we need to be more direct in helping out industry and have more transparent control of how money, power and policy gets distributed. Maybe have a New Deal type jobs program to repair infrastructure, or institute basic income, instead of these convoluted systems. But the more conservative reader, will probably look at this say, these manipulations are perversions and failures, had they not taken place, we would have had a more dynamic, faster, efficient system.
- 13thLetter 11y ago"Well maybe it was true in early 90s' But today if you include mandatory (entitlems) or just discretionary spending budget in the pie. Mandatory spending is dominated by medical (medicare etc) and social security. So that part doesn't sound right. Anyone know more?" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_United_States_federal_budget https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_United_States_federal_bud... Defense was third, behind Medicare/Medicaid and Social Security. So no, it's not right. They may have been interpreting discretionary spending as the whole thing, in which case defense is the largest single piece.
- obrero 11y agoThe DoD is the third biggest agency but does not include Veterans Affairs (3.7% of budget), the State Department (1.6% of budget), Homeland Security (1.5%), or the CIA (1.4%). I don't even include the DoE, which among other things handles nukes, or NASA which launches military satellites, has secret mission itineraries etc. Then you also have to count that portion of the interest on the debt that was due to past military spending. The amount of military spending the US government does is higher than what you are presenting.
- 13thLetter 11y agoIf you're going to lump together everything even tenuously connected to the military (all of NASA? all of the State Department? all of the Department of Energy?), I'd feel entitled to lump together everything that sends out checks, and the military would still be smaller -- much smaller, in fact. Interest on the debt isn't going to help you either, as we'd have to slice out the entitlements portion of that as well. And, of course, this doesn't even get into the question of whether the amount of military spending is right or wrong. "Look at this huge number! It's bigger than this other number!" isn't a meaningful argument. "This number is bigger than it should be, and here's why" is.
- obrero 11y ago> If you're going to lump together everything even tenuously connected to the military (all of NASA? all of the State Department? all of the Department of Energy?) I very clearly said I am not going to lump together NASA and the DoE. Now you're claiming to people, who can clearly read my post, that I did lump them in, when I explicitly did not lump then it. I do lump the State Department in with the military, as it's all more or less the same thing, beyond even that the CIA etc. routinely uses the State Department for cover ( http://voices.washingtonpost.com/spy-talk/2010/06/state_dept_loses_round_in_cia.html http://voices.washingtonpost.com/spy-talk/2010/06/state_dept... ). Foreign embassies that have the ambassador go out and threaten the other state's executive with US military intervention can't really be considered on the domestic social spending side of this military/social breakdown that is being discussed. > It's bigger than this other number The point is that military spending was being presented as smaller than it is - by saying veteran's benefits were not part of military spending etc.