3 ms·
Trial by combat, at least the modern understanding of it, is a myth. It was an extraordinarily rare event. People forget that it was meant to always end in de
by sandworm101 11y ago
Trial by combat, at least the modern understanding of it, is a myth. It was an extraordinarily rare event. People forget that it was meant to always end in death. Even if you survived combat, as the looser you were proven a liar before god and executed. Trial by combat was a threat used to prevent parties from swearing oaths casually, something useful only in extremely religious societies and totally out of place today. Letting people beat each other up over petty debts or teenage romances is never appropriate.
There is a dispute resolution mechanism for criminals. It's called organized crime. The boss decides.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoI don't know about judicially sanctioned dueling, but many private duels were not actually lethal. The terms were often set to first blood, meaning first to strike a wound wins. I'm not entirely certain of whether lethal dueling should be permissible, but complete prohibition might not be in order, either.
- sandworm101 11y agoA dual isn't trial by combat. Dueling was about honor, not debts, and has never been recognized by the law as a means for settling disputes. Whether in the east or west, it was basically a game for rich kids wanting to play soldier in front of the girls.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoIt was once recognized in Uruguay, ostensibly: http://www.deseretnews.com/article/235374/URUGUAY-RESCINDS-LAW-ALLOWING-DISPUTES-TO-BE-SETTLED-BY-DUEL.html?pg=all http://www.deseretnews.com/article/235374/URUGUAY-RESCINDS-L...
- chrisco255 11y agoWe have on record examples of former US Presidents who solved their differences with duels: http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/andrew-jackson-kills-charles-dickinson-in-duel http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/andrew-jackson-ki...
- apo 11y agoNot to mention standing Vice President Burr, who killed Alexander Hamilton in a duel. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burr–Hamilton_duel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burr–Hamilton_duel
- sandworm101 11y agoThose are really just honor disputes between rich kids, old kids but still kids. It's not like a court is going to dismiss a defamation action on the basis that it had already been settled during a previous duel, or award money to the winner. I don;t use the term 'rich' lightly. Worldwide, dualing has been a game for the wealthy. You had to have the right to carry the weapon, usually a sword. Lower classes were generally not allowed to duel.
- fsloth 11y agoI presume you mean duel as a state sanctioned part of the judicial proceedings? Lethal (sometimes illegal) dueling had very strong traditions in europe. Quite a few markable persons perished due to this culture, including: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Évariste_Galois https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Évariste_Galois
- sandworm101 11y agoTrial by combat is a judicial proceeding to determine guilt or innocence. Even if the matter is one of property or contract, the issue at combat is which of the two parties has committed perjury. The concept is that God will step in to aid the righteous party, similar to the very different 'trial by ordeal'. Dueling is a means of resolving disputes between individuals, normally over matter of honour or defamation. Or women. There is some crossover in terms, with some courts referring to trial by combat as a dueling, but it isn't the same thing. Dueling traditions normally involve a great many steps to avoid legal repercussions The modern version of dueling is probably streetracing. Kids+honor+danger+girls+illegality+expensive toys = occasional deaths.
- fsloth 11y ago"The modern version of dueling is probably streetracing." I never thought of that. Excitement, peer notoriety, girls. I agree it fits.
- wtbob 11y ago> People forget that it was meant to always end in death. Even if you survived combat, as the looser you were proven a liar before god and executed. From the historical resources I've reviewed, I don't know that was always the case, although in the case of capital crimes of course that would have held. At least it some situations, it looks like it was meant to be a formalised might-makes-right. > Letting people beat each other up over petty debts or teenage romances is never appropriate. Why not? If it formalises the process and becomes a mechanism through which both parties may be reintegrated to society at large, then it seems preferable to vendetta.