2 ms·
> That is not a successful betting strategy even if it's true. If we can determine the outcome, why is it not a successful betting strategy? > It's just chari
by pron 11y ago
> That is not a successful betting strategy even if it's true.
If we can determine the outcome, why is it not a successful betting strategy?
> It's just charity.
For something to be charity, you need to determine that the receiver does not rightfully deserve it, and the giver does. That distinction relies on values, and every person may come up with a different labeling of something as charity or not. I studied history and my views are largely shaped by that. I believe that the current distribution of power and resources in society is largely a result of what you may call "charity" to the people who are now rich (and that's putting it very kindly).
> Which is what we need to know unless we're specifically trying to change something.
As what we do or don't do determine the outcome, any decision is a political choice. Saying that we're specifically trying to change something is no different from saying that we're specifically trying to keep something the same. Today's bet is tomorrows outcome, and you must place a bet.
> Just looking at e.g. the racial composition of the output doesn't actually tell you if anything is wrong.
We liberals have an assumption. It is no more arbitrary than conservative assumptions. The assumption is that -- unless proven otherwise -- no group of people wishes to yield power over themselves to others, and that different groups have similar capacity for "power-gaining" achievement. Therefore, if we look at the racial or sexual makeup of a certain source of social power and we find a gross disparity, we want to balance it.
> It could be (and often will be) that the algorithm is measuring other things that are correlated with race.
Absolutely. The problem is not what the algorithm tells you, but what you do with the information. Because what determines the future outcome is not the output of the algorithm, but your decision on how to act.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> If we can determine the outcome, why is it not a successful betting strategy? Because the bet is for what happens today but what the bet changes is what happens the next year or the next generation. It's giving someone a car loan when you know they're likely to default and then pay pennies on the dollar in collections. They will then have paid half the market price for their car and you will have paid the other half. That is clearly not profitable for you so doing it on purpose is charity. > For something to be charity, you need to determine that the receiver does not rightfully deserve it, and the giver does. Gibberish. Charity means giving to the less fortunate. The robber barons were terrible but you can't arbitrarily redefine words in order to claim they didn't give to charity. And you're missing the point. I don't care what you call it, if your goal is to have the government take from the rich and give to the poor then just do that. Collect simple taxes and then give the money away. Don't come up with weird complicated economically distorting contortions with large and hard to predict negative externalities. > As what we do or don't do determine the outcome, any decision is a political choice. Saying that we're specifically trying to change something is no different from saying that we're specifically trying to keep something the same. Of course it's a political choice, but that doesn't tell you anything about what should be done or not done. And saying you're specifically trying to change something tells people what you're specifically trying to change. > Therefore, if we look at the racial or sexual makeup of a certain source of social power and we find a gross disparity, we want to balance it. But your categories are arbitrary. Race is a thing idiots made up. It isn't a real thing, it's a social construct. What justifies groups to be defined as they are? Why don't we also care about the economic disparities (which actually exist) between Irish Americans and English Americans? Or short and tall? Ugly and pretty? Consider whether the reason is because those lines don't map with existing political coalitions. Everyone who is not born rich is so because of some historical misfortune not shared by their rich-born contemporaries. That's the line that sums up all the other lines. If you want to help the poor, help the poor. If you find a specific instance of racial discrimination (as in causation not correlation) then stamp it out. But Mercedes is not doing something wrong or obligated to do something different just because there is a racial disparity in who can afford their cars.
- pron 11y ago> Don't come up with weird complicated economically distorting contortions with large and hard to predict negative externalities. I am not trying to. I am simply pointing out that treating past data as a future predictor and acting accordingly on the assumption that the social structure doesn't change as a result of your actions is a conservative political action; not a neutral one, and certainly not an objective one justified by "math". > It isn't a real thing, it's a social construct. A social construct is often as real as it gets. > What justifies groups to be defined as they are? You're looking at it the other way around. If someone arbitrarily makes up a group (say, race), and based on that arbitrary bias creates a social structure where that group is discriminated against and marginalized from power, fixing this bias is correcting an unfairness. We're not trying to make up groups in order to fix the situation; the groups had already been made up in the process of doing the wrong. > But Mercedes is not doing something wrong or obligated to do something different just because there is a racial disparity in who can afford their cars. I never said that that what they're doing is wrong. But a society that is not telling Mercedes to treat data differently is carrying out a conservative policy. I am not saying that changing that particular behavior is where we should best direct our efforts at change, but I am saying that we shouldn't pretend there's anything neutral about acting in this way. I am also not saying that people (or companies) have a responsibility to individually act against their self interest; that's not how Nash equilibria are escaped anyway, so that's just not going to work. Social action is best done through consensus and compromise. Just as political systems now cooperate on not changing things, they can cooperate on changing them.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> I am simply pointing out that treating past data as a future predictor and acting accordingly on the assumption that the social structure doesn't change as a result of your actions is a conservative political action; not a neutral one, and certainly not an objective one justified by "math". That doesn't actually mean anything. All action and inaction has consequences. There is no neutral. An algorithm is objective because it's falsifiable. If you're trying to predict e.g. whether someone will pay back a loan then every time the algorithm tells us to make the loan we can see if it was right. We can also take a random statistical sample from the times it says not to make the loan and do it anyway to find out what happens then. And if the algorithm made bad predictions then we can improve it. Now suppose we have a nice algorithm. Best available information. Prediction accuracy very good. It says the risk of John not paying back the loan is higher than the value of any reasonable interest the lender could charge. There is now an obvious objectively correct answer to the question of whether the lender should typically loan John the money, if the lender wants to stay in business. It isn't "neutral" because nothing is. But it is unaffected by John's race. > A social construct is often as real as it gets. We made it, we can unmake it. The low income housing people proved that concentrating poverty is dangerous. You put all the low income housing together and it becomes a slum. You put one or two low income units in each of several middle class neighborhoods and they don't. Grouping a vulnerable population together has the same danger. It draws an imaginary line around them, separating them from everyone else, concentrating their shared troubles and isolating people who need help from people who could provide it. Grouping humans by "race" is poison, even if you're trying to help. > You're looking at it the other way around. If someone arbitrarily makes up a group (say, race), and based on that arbitrary bias creates a social structure where that group is discriminated against and marginalized from power, fixing this bias is correcting an unfairness. You didn't create the groups but you're choosing which ones to care about. There are so many different groups that meet those criteria that you'll never meet someone who isn't in at least one of them. And they correlate and half-correlate and complement each other. You can't balance that. But you also can't balance it because humans are not a fungible commodity. They're not equivalent. If you have fifty white coal miners, ten black doctors and three white CEOs, and you just average their salaries and say "white people have an advantage" because the CEOs each make a billion dollars, the coal miners are going to disagree with you and have a legitimate point. Let's even pretend we can balance humans to see how quickly absurdity follows. So the problem we want to solve is that there are a higher proportion of low income black Americans than white Americans. OK, so we either need fewer low income black Americans or more low income white Americans. Possibility: Eject some low income black Americans. Nope, violates our principles and the US constitution. (But the fact that it would otherwise be effective should make you suspicious.) Next possibility: Get more low income white Americans. There are millions of low income people in eastern Europe who would like to be US citizens, so we let them. Hurray! Racial disparity in America solved! If what we really care about is "balance" then that is an actual solution, but it's also so obviously ridiculous that it demonstrates how that can't possibly be the real problem. And if it is to be a real problem then it also demonstrates why you can't solve it. Because the opposite of that is what has been happening. A large proportion of existing white American families immigrated here after the abolition of slavery. They, at a minimum, had enough wealth and education to afford passage (in the early days) and gain American citizenship (in modern times). So they've been bringing up the average the whole time. You're trying to balance an open system.