4 ms·
> One unspoken objection to raising the minimum wage is that people, other people, those people, will get paid a little more. Which might make getting ahead a l
by golergka 11y ago
> One unspoken objection to raising the minimum wage is that people, other people, those people, will get paid a little more. Which might make getting ahead a little harder. When we raise the bottom, this thinking goes, it gets harder to move to the top.
What a ridiculous strawman to attack. Author didn't even try to prove that this "unspoken objection" actually exists, he just enjoyed the fantasy of evil man in suits so much.
- enraged_camel 11y agoThere are a lot of studies that prove the mentality exists. I forget where I read it, but they did a study where they gave the participant two choices: they get $140 and their neighbor gets $160, or they get $120 and their neighbor gets $100. A significant portion chose the latter option.
- dexterdog 11y agoDefine significant.
- jdreaver 11y agoI think the word "prove" is very strong when it comes to a psychological study that measures something indirectly. I agree with your parent comment. I doubt the author was even thinking of such studies when they wrote that part of the article.
- hodwik 11y agoAnd they should, the value of the dollar is relative to the total in the economy. I suspect, because the question was even asked, the participants read into the study as a question of economics. I would have done the same thing. Assuming the two people make up the total economy; $120 out of a total $220 is a greater amount of money than is $140 out of $300.
- stdbrouw 11y agoThat seems a little far-fetched. You ask someone about distributing cash between them and their neighbor and of course the participant will assume that what you're talking about is their wealth relative to the sum total wealth of the entire world or the effects of large-scale inflation?
- hodwik 11y agoThe inflationary nature of money is heavily tied into our subconscious experience of it. If you ask the same question , but about things rather than dollars, people will make the rational choice. "Would you rather have a yacht if your neighbor has two yachts, or a dingy, and your neighbor doesn't have a boat?" Everyone will answer yachts, because yachts aren't subconsciously inflationary. "Would you rather have ten books and your neighbor has fifteen, or five books and your neighbor has three?" "Would you rather own three pairs of shoes and your neighbor owns four, or two pairs of shoes and your neighbor owns one?" Also, the very fact they're asking the question in a study causes people to answer differently than they would normally -- that's the problem with this sort of 'science' to begin with. It's always this sort of Gotcha! science. People are used to that. As a result, most people, when they're answering questions in a study are thinking "These are trick questions. I won't be a guinea pig. What is the underlying trick here?" --- Addendum: The study may also be dealing with a cultural difference in the use of the phrase "your neighbor". In the southern Christian tradition "your neighbor" is a catch-all for people that you are not related to (from Mark 12:31).
- stdbrouw 11y agoYou do see the irony in criticizing a study for its imperfection when you yourself rely on nothing more than your personal guesstimate of what "most people" think and a just-so story about the possible influence of an obscure biblical interpretation, right? I agree with your general point, many of these kinds of psychological studies lack all external validity (they don't measure what they think they measure). It just surprised me that instead of "you know, I have my doubts" your original post went straight for "this empirical research is wrong because my unsubstantiated theorizing is right."
- Qwertious 11y agoIf I were offered a free $20, my first thought would not be "should I turn this money down because it's metaphorical for the economy?". Also, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimatum_game https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimatum_game
- golergka 11y ago1) It's certainly not the same logic as "When we raise the bottom, this thinking goes, it gets harder to move to the top.". 2) Still, the author didn't even link these studies in his post.
- goodJobWalrus 11y agoRight. Also, I read that most people that object minimum wage increase are those that are just a little above it themselves. That exactly explains what Godin talks about here. Those people won't have anyone to feel superior to if they lose their tiny wage differential.
- hodwik 11y agoWho is better positioned to tell you about the dis-incentivization of minimum wage than those who have recently worked hard to get above it?
- goodJobWalrus 11y agoYeah, right, I am sure they only have society's best interest at heart, after the careful consideration of 'dis-incentivization of minimum wage'....although I'm not sure why you think they have all 'recently worked hard to get above it'. I would think it's more likely these are two distinct classes that don't intersect that much.
- mjirv 11y agoStudies also show that people are happier when their income makes them relatively most wealthy compared to their peers, so this seems reasonable.
- cmiles74 11y agoThe article is weak on substance, but they did offer the example of the unsuccessful "all first class" airline flight.
- mcbrown 11y agoSee my comment on why that is a poor example.
- jakejake 11y agoI think to there is also an attitude about minimum wage going up that - hey it's great they get raise. But if 75% of the country is getting a raise why am I not getting a raise as well? Or for some people who worked hard to get up from minimum wage to get to $10/hour. They are now, in a way, demoted back to making minimum wage!
- Absentinsomniac 11y agoEh, I work in the service sector and when everyone was bumped to 9/hr I got bumped to 10. It wasn't a 1 to 1 bump but only like 2 people complained. Not sure how financially viable this is for other companies, but we're a median sized grocery chain. At any rate isn't it a little weird that it feels so bad that other people start at a higher rate than I did? Kinda like how some people have rich parents and others don't... Maybe there's a comparison here. Course if prices adjust this is null, but I don't think small min. wage bumps will cause prices to adjust.
- jakejake 11y agoThat's fair at least you got recognized with a salary increase. Just curious, would you have been a little upset if everybody got bumped up $9 and you didn't get a raise so you stayed there at $9 with everybody?
- Absentinsomniac 11y agoYes, I don't know why really. I actually started at like 8
- mcguire 11y ago"Author didn't even try to prove that this "unspoken objection" actually exists, he just enjoyed the fantasy of evil man in suits so much." Note: pot, kettle, black.
- pns 11y agoI agree Seth doesn't make the strongest points for the broader message he's getting at. That said, I find it a useful because there's still value in his words to be taken. As John Stuart Mill says in On Liberty: "Though the silenced opinion be an error, it may, and very commonly does, contain a portion of truth"[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Liberty#Of_the_liberty_of_thought_and_discussion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Liberty#Of_the_liberty_of_t...