6 ms·
Packed extra dense? They could no doubt shave a few inches here and there, but the basics of parking remain. (1) They would have to have lanes, else every car
by sandworm101 11y ago
Packed extra dense? They could no doubt shave a few inches here and there, but the basics of parking remain.
(1) They would have to have lanes, else every car have to move every time someone wanted out. And these lanes would have to be wide enough that the car with the largest turning radius could still get out reasonably.
(2) There would still need to be some standard width for spaces, else a thin car leaving would leave a 3-4' wide space that nobody else could fit into. And a thin car moving into the gap left by a wide car wouldn't be very efficient.
(3) Accommodation would still be needed for humans/pedestrians to deal with issues or rescue stuck cars.
(4) The new nightmare of the loading area outside stores as autodrive cars line up like cabs at the airport pickup up passengers. At least in a parking lot everyone can load/unload without forcing everyone else to wait.
(5) The fire safety rules would still apply. Deep in building codes are provisions for exactly how much of various dangerous things are allowed inside parking lots. A bunch of tightly-packed, battery packed, teslas in a big concrete box is a firefighter's nightmare.
Imho far more space could be saved in north america if parking lots had better accommodation for motorcycles. Everyone who rides a bike rather than drive a car effectively saves 3/4 of a parking space if spots are made for them.
- mcbutterbunz 11y agoNot to mention you wouldn't be able to box cars in. You still need to be able to pull the car ou, with or without a driver. This is just a personal valet service which is still exciting.
- op00to 11y agoWhy can't you box cars in? When I park in an attended lot in NYC and Philly, my car is often boxed in because space is so tight. I either tell them when I expect to be back or wait for them to jockey cars around. With self driving cars, it could be straightforward to program them to move around to extricate a boxed in vehicle.
- zachrose 11y agoAnd also win big at Rush Hour: http://www.amazon.com/Think-Fun-5000-ThinkFun-Rush/dp/B00000DMER http://www.amazon.com/Think-Fun-5000-ThinkFun-Rush/dp/B00000...
- CamperBob2 11y ago(1) They would have to have lanes, else every car have to move every time someone wanted out. Which is no longer necessarily a problem.
- sandworm101 11y agoWhy? Are all of these cars going to automagically cooperate in some sort of parking ballet every time the guy at the back wants out?
- colechristensen 11y agoWhy not? Valets do this all the time.
- ceejayoz 11y agoEventually, why not?
- sandworm101 11y agoBecause the human valet is effectively a common control system. To get all the cars to do this without humans they would need to be networked and agree some common communication standards. Cars aren't cellphones. The chances of a few hundred random vehicles, covering perhaps 20 different model years, all dancing together is a pipe dream.
- raldi 11y agoThey're not random vehicles. The special lots would only be for the cars with this feature. If 100% of Teslas, BMW's, and Apple Cars supported it, you'd quickly see a bunch of other automakers get on board (Why not? If the car can already self-park, this isn't much harder from that point.) At first, it would just be a few lots in the densest parts of cities. Within, I don't know, seven years, you'd be seeing them all over the place. Every shopping mall would have a special area for them, right near the entrance. Oh, and don't forget: Cars of the near future (and Teslas today) can have features like this added years after leaving the factory, as an over-the-air software update.
- zhte415 11y agoI'm thinking 3D. A cuboid parking area where the car rests/charges, stacked high, wide and deep of cars. No need for regular staff access. When a car is needed it disengages, connects with a ramp/lift loading/unloading platform, and drives itself to you.
- sandworm101 11y agoThat's getting much more complicated than the concrete slab that is a parking lot today. Cars on lifts/ramps hauled by robots has been done many times, but its far from cheap and has never caught on. It just requires too much maintenance. Valets are cheaper.
- ricardobeat 11y agoIsn't that a very common sight in Japan? The cost of land in metropolitan areas easily overshadows a bunch of hydraulics and elevators produced at scale.
- culturestate 11y agoMany companies already make similar products for parking, e.g. [1]. The autonomous, unoccupied drive to the parking structure and being connected to power without human intervention are the more pressing problems. 1. http://www.parkmatic.com http://www.parkmatic.com
- JshWright 11y ago> A bunch of tightly-packed, battery packed, teslas in a big concrete box is a firefighter's nightmare. That's certainly moderately concerning, but I can assure you a firefighter's nightmares are far darker...
- FireBeyond 11y agoPretty much. Confronted with a parking lot of burning electric cars, I might point some deck guns and aerials at it, but it'll be more "watch it burn". Risk a little for a little. It's insured property, not savable life(s).
- sandworm101 11y agoUnless this is an underground lot and there is a worry that the heat of 300 burning teslas might do something to the building above. It would at least give off some nasty fumes. Someone will want that one car put out before it propagates. And is water the correct thing to throw on a few hundred pounds of burning lithum batteries? I really don't know, but I suspect not.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- DrScump 11y agothe heat of 300 burning teslas "300 Burning Teslas" sounds like a band name.
- semi-extrinsic 11y ago
- rubberstamp 11y agoOnce that happens, it wouldn't be just tesla's that will be auto parking densely. Any other car is equally susceptible to cause fire as all cars have batteries and most have inflammable fuel. Its not yet here, but auto parking densely probably meant cars can be tightly packed as you don't have to leave enough space for you to open doors. As the car is self driving, it can go to the garage and park next to some other car. Its doable now, if those garages have some sort of beacon to notify unoccupied space and if all cars have beacons to notify/detect its edges. Its not hard to implement at all.
- agumonkey 11y agoIt's funny because dense packing is also a problem for Tesla batteries. They had to leave gaps for security.