5 ms·
How does the GPL prevent them from making money? Sure, I have essentially the source code of someone's processor, but unless I have millions of dollars to fabri
by colejohnson66 11y ago
How does the GPL prevent them from making money? Sure, I have essentially the source code of someone's processor, but unless I have millions of dollars to fabricate a chip, the source's only use is to learn how things work.
Intel, if they wanted to, could release the source code of their microcode for their processors under the GPLv2 and not provide the signing certificate (like TiVo did), and all people would be able to do with it is study it. What am I gonna do with the source code of a processor? Build an emulator? I already have the instruction manual...
- nickpsecurity 11y agoMain reply here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10873839 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10873839 Microcode is a separate issue that's debateable. Their CPU hardware, patents, logistics, ecosystem, and branding are real source of revenue. Microcode release might nit hurt them. However, it might contain trade secret methods for utilizing hardware in a clever way that could give competition (mainly startups) an edge. Biggest players, esp AMD, probably already RE'd it. That said, Im for opening up microcode and even push for microcoded RISC-V. The reason is you can do all kinds of stuff from optimizing algorithms to atomic functions. There were also HLL-to-microcode compilers in the past to make it easier. Look up PALcode on Alpha ISA if you want a nice hybrid, too.
- userbinator 11y agoThat said, Im for opening up microcode and even push for microcoded RISC-V. You mean a CISC-V? ;-)
- nickpsecurity 11y agoLol. Clever. I'll keep it Microcoded RISC-V until people start doing something bloated like emulating x86 in it. ;) cough Loongson people cough
- marcoperaza 11y agoIntel has competitors. Why would Intel want to provide its competitors with what must be, at the very least, tens of millions of dollars worth of work?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYou have the right idea but it's way more that you think. Intel spends over a billion dollars per quarter on all their tech. https://ycharts.com/companies/INTC/r_and_d_expense https://ycharts.com/companies/INTC/r_and_d_expense I agree R&D on any given bit of HW design is at least tens of millions. Probably more than once per year going back a decade given it's custom and formally verified. Standard cell approximating that would be a fraction of it but still ridiculously high if aiming for competitive performance/watt.
- marcoperaza 11y agoYeah, Intel is one of the biggest companies in the world. I was just speculating an absolute floor for just the microcode in particular.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYou're the second person to bring up microcode. I'm curious why two are focused on this rather than the HW itself. What about you? Note: For readers not in the know, microcode is the sequence of wiring activations of the physical, closed hardware. Instructions, merely series of bits, get translated to that by the microcode engine running from a memory rather than hardwired engine. Unlike the ISA, it's highly tied to the hardware since it drives it directly.
- marcoperaza 11y agoI'm not focused on this, it was an example used in the post I responded to.
- 11y ago