4 ms·
As a counterpoint consider this other case of a rape accusation that the accuser admitted she'd made up: https://www.propublica.org/article/false-rape-accusati
by ZeroGravitas 11y ago
As a counterpoint consider this other case of a rape accusation that the accuser admitted she'd made up:
https://www.propublica.org/article/false-rape-accusations-an-unbelievable-story https://www.propublica.org/article/false-rape-accusations-an...
In that case, actual objective facts did eventually allow us to judge things objectively.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoThis doesn't really address any of the issues with prosecuting rape. If you accuse me of raping you on the 4th of April 2011, and I document that I was in a different country at the time, it's pretty easy to say that I'm innocent. But rape isn't a crime of being in a particular country; that was incidental. The problem with rape prosecutions is that it isn't possible, under any circumstances, to demonstrate that a rape did occur. Depending on incidental details, it might be easy to demonstrate that it didn't, or, more generously, that it didn't happen as reported (maybe I really did rape you, but it was in 2009!). When you have two people, and one claims to have been raped while the other claims that what in fact happened was that they had consensual sex, there is no evidence that can distinguish one claim from the other (this is why evidence of the woman's sexual history was historically offered in rape cases -- it's not perfect, but it at least directly addresses this problem). The only difference is in the mind of the person claiming rape. We've decided to solve that problem by saying that it's fine if a bunch of people are jailed based on no evidence. The traditional answer was that it basically wasn't possible to prosecute people for rape, because it couldn't be demonstrated. Both of those are bad things -- but we shouldn't pretend that rape prosecutions are based in facts, just so we can say that all of the bad is on the other side.
- tptacek 11y agoI would be careful with singling out the crime of rape for this concern, because contrary to a very popular opinion on message boards, lots of crimes result in convictions without smoking-gun physical evidence. In fact, you'd expect trials with smoking-gun physical evidence to be somewhat rare: if the DA can easily prove you're guilty, they're going to tell you that to get you to plead out. Meanwhile, rape has historically been under-prosecuted (within many of our lifetimes, marital rape was exempted from prosecution! That's how new rigorous rape prosecution is).
- thaumasiotes 11y agoI agree with your entire comment above. But rape was under-prosecuted (excluding marital rape) for the reasons I'm talking about (they're called out in several legal and law-related texts), and it's a near-perfect exemplar of the problem, because the difference between criminal and legal conduct is so fine/intangible. We used to have underprosecution of rape because of concerns about the possible legal basis for prosecutions. I'm not sure that the spread of the reverse phenomenon, prosecutions unconcerned with their own legal basis because it's imperative to prosecute certain terrible things regardless of the evidence, is something to cheerlead for.
- tptacek 11y agoI think you've missed the more important part of my comment. For instance, when Hans Reiser was accused of murdering his wife, message boards were in uproar about the near total lack of physical evidence, not just of Hans Reiser's culpability but that Nina Reiser had even died. But the court system didn't skip a beat; circumstantial evidence is routinely assessed by juries.
- pvg 11y agoNot the best of examples as the court system offered him a deal. His own hubris is what put him in front of a jury and kept him from nearly getting away with pre-meditated murder.
- tptacek 11y agoWhat does that have to do with the quality of the physical evidence used to convict him?
- pvg 11y agoThe prosecutors (and judge) thought the circumstantial case against him was so weak, they were prepared to let him walk away with 3 years (most of which he'd already served), didn't want him to face a jury, etc. He didn't take their deal and his decision to testify was, by all accounts, a significant factor in his conviction. Almost everything about this particular is case is the opposite of the point you're making.