4 ms·
It is odd to see advertisers speak of tracking so casually. Tracking is still new. Up until a few years ago (like 3) the majority of the industry (by money) d
by sandworm101 11y ago
It is odd to see advertisers speak of tracking so casually. Tracking is still new. Up until a few years ago (like 3) the majority of the industry (by money) did not track users. A huge, but admittedly declining, segment still don't.
Billboards do not track. TV ads do not track. Physical shop fronts do not track. Radio ads do not track. And a great many website still sell space to people selling actual products, rather than banner ads, which bypasses all adblockers.
There are plenty of ways to get your message out, and make money in return, without inventing new supercookies for me to ferret out of my system.
- geocar 11y agoBoth Outdoors and Television do the same by-demographic buying/selling, in fact, that's where the Internet got it! Outdoors and Television don't track (except when they do[1]) because they don't need to; because there exists a huge problem with digital that doesn't exist for Outdoors and Television: Ad Fraud. There are a lot of websites out there with a lot of (aggregate) traffic, but that individually don't have enough traffic to approach advertisers directly. It is good that we can monetise them because sometimes this can fund their niche content, however it also means that people can make fake websites and trick advertisers into buying that space. Of course, real users don't go to those sites, which is a nascent use for tracking: Sites that are visited by some population who don't visit other sites are simply more suspicious. [1]: Precision Marketing (for example) has data on billboards collected from mobile devices. Many OTT and SmartTV devices send tracking data as well.
- cpeterso 11y agoHave there been studies showing how much, if at all, user tracking improves ad clickthrough or revenue?
- geocar 11y agoYes to both, but I am suspicious about most of the mathematics used to prove uplift and conversions using micro-models because of simple counter-examples like the blank ad[1] that generated a median clickthrough rate, and because of the prevalence of one-tailed "dropoff" charts don't pass the laugh test. For more on this phenomenon, there's a book[2] that I'm oft to recommend. Nevertheless, I also believe there are genuine means for revenue that utilise user tracking, but this is more work and attention than the typical digital ad campaign receives. [1]: http://adage.com/article/digital/incredible-click-rate/236233/ http://adage.com/article/digital/incredible-click-rate/23623... [2]: http://www.amazon.co.uk/How-Lie-Statistics-Penguin-Business/dp/0140136290 http://www.amazon.co.uk/How-Lie-Statistics-Penguin-Business/...
- a3n 11y ago> TV ads do not track. Are we sure about that? Smart TVs would seem to make this at least possible, and probably easy.
- J_Darnley 11y agoOf course a smart TV tracks you. That's why the manufacturer made it (to earn money from you over its lifetime). The other features it has are just the bait on the hook.
- sandworm101 11y agoWhich is why I tell everyone to avoid SmartTVs and instead use some form of media player to support networking. It means yet another remote, but given that my TV remotes have already been usurped by my isp-provided decoder box. (Also a good idea as players are cheaper to replace than TVs.)
- cpeterso 11y agoTVs may not track yet, but phones or PCs are already tracking the TV ads people are watching: "Beware of ads that use inaudible sound to link your phone, TV, tablet, and PC. Privacy advocates warn feds about surreptitious cross-device tracking." http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/11/beware-of-ads-that-use-inaudible-sound-to-link-your-phone-tv-tablet-and-pc/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/11/beware-of-ads-tha...
- nitrogen 11y agoTV ads can track using inaudible watermarks picked up by other household devices (especially apps running on phones; arstechnica wrote about this). Probably similar with radio ads. Physical stores track using Wifi, Bluetooth, and cellphone signals. Billboards could conceivably do the same. The world is creepier than most consumers imagine, and it needs to stop.
- avn2109 11y ago>> "Billboards do not track." A competently-designed out of home ad setup will probably at least make an attempt to track its audience, often by doing some sort of telemetry to your smartphone or by literally photographing you as you pass by. [0-1] I don't work for these outfits but a lot of people erroneously believe the "billboards don't track" claim. [0] http://web.admobilize.com/ http://web.admobilize.com/ [1] http://www.quividi.com/applications.html http://www.quividi.com/applications.html