4 ms·
Check out this nightmare of a system China is implementing to use gamification to control populations: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lHcTKWiZ8sI https://m.yout
by samstave 11y ago
Check out this nightmare of a system China is implementing to use gamification to control populations:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lHcTKWiZ8sI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lHcTKWiZ8sI
- rubberstamp 11y agoYes, I read about that some time ago. Unfortunately, unless the people stop using that system or actively games it, its a disaster. I bet things will get better in china in 30 years. If the current Chinese form of government was better serving people, there would be no dissent and hence no need to create a surveillance state. Its neither communism or democracy.
- rashkov 11y agoOh, my god. I've read about this before but that link really drove the point home. What a dystopia we're headed for if this works out well for China, and there is every reason to believe that it could. Thanks for sharing that
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoOh its ok for corporations in the USA to do this to control purchasing and marketing. But do it for some actual societal good and suddenly its (more) evil? I'm of two minds on this one. Gamification works in lots of arenas (from pizza coupons to annual reviews). Why not social/public morals?
- rashkov 11y agoI'm not sure how you can watch the parent's youtube link and still compare the two. They are in different leagues altogether, in my opinion, so I'm finding it hard to relate to your comment. I think it's also pretty hard to define "social/public morals" in a way that is agreeable to most people. Would not linking to tiananmen square, or discussing China's stock market slide be a public good? Are you really comfortable with that kind of censorship?
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoRemember people are not mindless drones. These games are there to let you know how you're expected to behave (like tax incentives, street signs etc). This is different, sure. But not unprecedented.
- rashkov 11y agoWhat's different, however, is the level of coordinated surveillance that enables this scheme, as well as the centralized power of coercion that the state yields. Ad-tech companies, financials, silicon valley data silos, surveillance bodies, and most importantly the government are not legally able to coordinate on a level that would allow let them baldly track your purchasing history, your social media presence, as well as your private communications and then assign you an aggregate score! Besides the legal separation issues, their interests aren't nearly as aligned with each other as in the case of China so there are some checks and balances. Then to take that aggregate score and further coerce you by making loans scarce or jobs unavailable is a whole other level. What we're talking about is a totalitarian system of control over the population. Tweaked and targeted on an extremely personal level, and leveraging social pressure and shame. Say what you will about the malevolence of the US government and our capitalistic system but it is simply incapable of this scale of totalitarianism.
- samstave 11y ago100% 1984 on steroids! It's nuts - and this is what people should revolt against. Fight club was a documentary :-)