4 ms·
Forbes started having rando bloggers post articles to part of their website a couple years ago. I guess they wouldn't have done that if they thought they were t
by maxerickson 11y ago
Forbes started having rando bloggers post articles to part of their website a couple years ago. I guess they wouldn't have done that if they thought they were taken particularly seriously. One possibility is that they decided to get what they could out of the name while it was still worth anything.
- m0nty 11y agoSo they've jumped the shark anyway? Kind of hard for me to judge, because all I ever get is a blank gray page when I try to look at their articles.
- paulpauper 11y agoGive that their articles are everywhere when you go a google search, I'm sure they are making wheelbarrows full of money, even if the 'brand' suffers a bit. Print magazines written by professionals have been in decline for while now. User-generated content of mediocre quality is where it is now. That is the business model that makes the most money
- ghaff 11y agoBack in the Malcolm Forbes days, Forbes was one of the big three US business magazines--the others being Fortune and Business Week--and it was quite good. It was my favorite of the three and I subscribed to it for a number of years. It started declining at some point after Malcolm's death and for the past few years in particular the online site has really sold its soul for clicks. Some of its bloggers are decent but a lot of them have massive conflicts of interest of one sort or another and/or are more interested in being provocative than being thoughtful or correct. And BrandVoice really blurs the lines between advertising and editorial.
- smcnally 11y agoThere are many more writers on Forbes now than 5 years ago. You might not like them all. They may not all be of the same, high caliber. None of them are "randos" as the parent comment noted; they all come in with a body of work and a reputation and are vetted by editors. > a lot of them have massive conflicts of interest of one sort or another That hadn't been the case. With hope, it's still not. There are ~disclosures linked from every byline. There are points of view and interests, to be sure. Those interests should be at least as transparent as they are for Fortune, Business Week, The New York Times, et al. > more interested in being provocative than being thoughtful or correct Well-said. This has been the trajectory of news, entertainment, and the media in general for many decades. The web has helped accelerate it, but it's not proprietary to web publishers. > And BrandVoice really blurs the lines between advertising and editorial That's by design and intended to be so in a positive way: "don't just pitch products at me, but give me information I'll find useful or entertaining even if it does suit your agenda." My disclosure is I worked on BrandVoice and similar programs; I'm no longer with Forbes. My strong opinion is all media have forms of this ad/edit line-blurring via product placement, advertorial, sponsorships, and combinations of them all. (more on that https://medium.com/@sjkmcnally/you-call-e-t-a-movie-but-there-s-a-bag-of-reese-s-pieces-right-there-5d02b68ecd6f#.2dytgsug0 https://medium.com/@sjkmcnally/you-call-e-t-a-movie-but-ther... ) re the parent post, advertorial is one way publishers are making some money and, in part, paying writers to bring you news and entertainment. It doesn't directly involve malware and usually not even ad networks. It's not intended to disrupt reading experiences -- like pop-ups, take-overs, & pre-roll -- and all the tools are there for advertisers to disclose conflicts and provide some thoughtfulness & value to people who engage with it. When that's not the case 100% of the time, it's about specific executions rather than corruption of the concept as a whole.
- maxerickson 11y agoSo I went to Google, searched "Forbes", clicked "news" and then picked something I thought looked rando. Here's a personal finance/savvy consumer contributor that certainly isn't well known extolling lottery mysticism: http://www.forbes.com/sites/vanessamcgrady/2016/01/08/powerball/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/vanessamcgrady/2016/01/08/powerb... I agree that I totally cherry picked that example, at least, from the first 5 Google results.
- smcnally 11y ago(wow are there a ton of distracting ads on that article ...) Is this an example of conflict of interest? Or just of less-than-substantial "personal finance" content? The Contributor's bio has her bona fides and point of view. http://www.forbes.com/sites/vanessamcgrady/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/vanessamcgrady/ She's not Charlie Munger, but he didn't start out as Charlie Munger, either. The article is timely and relevant. "Powerball" in the article title is going to get play -- there's a multi-state, $900MM jackpot at stake tonight. Many Contributors are paid for the traffic they drive. Most Contributors like it when their stories are widely-read. Managing those incentives, the quality of content created, the creators themselves, and their reputations is an ongoing process for the Contributors, editors, and publishers involved. No doubt you could find more-glaring examples of less-than-substantial stories. One of my points is I'm glad this Contributor has a platform to create and publish her stories and build her community and career.
- maxerickson 11y agoRight, it's junk click bait designed to serve a pile of ads. I think it's awful that people are building a career by pretending that you can do better at the lotto (that's why I called it mysticism, you can't do better at the lotto). Someone who bills themselves as helping people be savvy consumers should be pointing out that the statistics for Powerball are basically insurmountable, not having fun pretending that there are ways to beat them. That doesn't mean I didn't buy a couple tickets for fun, but I also didn't spend a lot of time figuring out what numbers will work best to beat their random number generator.