6 ms·
This was a great writeup with lots of great information. One thing that bugged me though was the "When to Raise Money" section. It says, in part: "However, fo
by jedberg 11y ago
This was a great writeup with lots of great information. One thing that bugged me though was the "When to Raise Money" section. It says, in part: "However, for most it will require an idea, a product, and some amount of customer adoption, a.k.a. traction."
There was a great comment on HN a while back (I wish I remembered who said it) that said, "If you're asking about traction or revenue, you aren't making a seed investment".
Andy Bechtolsheim was a seed investor in Google -- he gave them a check based solely on their idea and who they were. Paul Graham/YC made a seed investment in reddit and Justin.tv and whole host of other companies -- none of them existed as more than idea when YC invested.
But VCs are risk averse people (ironic given they are in the risk business), so it makes sense that they would rather invest after a company can show a little traction, especially now that it's so easy to get that initial traction.
I just think we need a new term besides "seed" to differentiate it from the true seed investments.
- kapilkale 11y ago> especially now that it's so easy to get that initial traction It's gotten much cheaper to get traction. In some consumer markets, it is basically cost-free; all it takes is a motivated technical entrepreneur with a couple months of savings.
- cperciva 11y agoI agree that it's cheaper, but "a couple months of savings" != "cost-free".
- staunch 11y agoYou can't have very meaningful traction until you release an actual product. Most significant products (e.g. Dropbox) will take one person at least 6-12 months to develop, followed by 3+ months before there are charts showing traction. a) You raise money after having invested a year of work on your own dime. b) You raise money based on your connections/pedigree ("reputation").
- spuiszis 11y agoI kinda disagree, but it depends on the product/market. You can't pre-sell a nuclear fusion reactor before it's built (I'll bundle that with my swampland in Florida!) but there are ways to generate meaningful traction through list-building, pre-launch sales, commitments, etc. for SaaS apps that you could use to raise money. And frankly, that's what an entrepreneur should be doing in the first place to validate that you should be building that product for the target audience in the first place or that there is a market for your product. And you can always strip down your MVP to it's absolute core to get it out the door faster so you don't spend 6 months building it.
- mattmanser 11y agoI think you're wrong on the 6-12 months. Not boasting, but simply stating fact, that on my own, I've written: - A system for managing employee leave and sickness with google apps integration in 2 months - A credit control application for one of my clients in 3 weeks, automatic emails, dunning letters, cash-flow forecasting - A purchase order system that would automatically raise invoices in their accountancy system in 3-4 weeks - An entire search system a la booking.com in 4 weeks, with named location search, geo location, tags, categories, blah, blah, blah. Basically the heart of any listing style startup. And while I realize I'm a good programmer, I'm not a phenomenal programmer, I'm fairly lazy, I find it hard to focus on more than about 5 hours of actual programming unless I'm doing something really interesting. And these are some off the top of my head examples. I've written loads of small startup sized apps that would be of the complexity that YC fund in much less than 12 weeks, let alone 12 months. You're looking for an MVP with some traction, not a polished product. Reddit, for example, launched without the ability for users to create their own subreddits, and many would describe that as one of the key reasons of Reddit's growth. I believe they actually launched without commenting, but I can't find a source on that. While today's startups have more expected of them, it's now easier than ever to write a web app, even SPAs that even 3 or 4 years ago would be too hard for individuals to write on their own.
- jedberg 11y ago> Reddit, for example, launched without the ability for users to create their own subreddits, and many would describe that as one of the key reasons of Reddit's growth. I believe they actually launched without commenting, but I can't find a source on that. reddit launched with only voting and submitting of links (no self posts). Commenting, subreddit creation, self posts and all that was added years after launch. (Source: I was there :) )
- danieltillett 11y agoNot if what you want to build requires more than 0.5 to 1 developer years of work. There are a large family of problems that can only be tackled with 10+ developer years worth of work to get to a MVP.
- cookiecaper 11y agoCan you explain, step by step, the cheap, easy way to gain traction as a technical entrepreneur with a few months of savings? This sounds like an infomercial. I'm not sure what the cheap, easy route to gain traction would be unless it's "pay a spammer". If that is the predominant position in SV, it's good to know.
- cookiecaper 11y agoBummed out that no one has answered this. Maybe it's just something investors say so that it's easy to discard people and startups that aren't already obvious winners; "oh, you don't have enough traction for how long you've been up. Getting traction is super easy these days so you must be dumb. Next!"
- w1ntermute 11y agoIf you're the sort of person who has to get info from a website on how to raise a seed round, then you're probably not in a position to raise money based on just an idea or who you are.
- oneloop 11y agoWhat do you mean, get info? Do you think successful people just do stuff in the dark without any idea of what they're doing?
- w1ntermute 11y agoNo, they usually know other successful people to ask. Those who don't have to "get info from a website".
- S4M 11y agoSome people can have solid technical chops, a good idea and a working prototype and not know angels. Not everybody lives in Silicon Valley or some startup hubs. In fact, there is an essay from Paul Graham explaining why some of the best ideas come from outsiders [0]. [0] http://paulgraham.com/marginal.html http://paulgraham.com/marginal.html
- w1ntermute 11y agoSomeone who has the technical chops to build a prototype would be approaching an angel with a lot more than just an idea or who they are.
- ig1 11y agoIf you've got a strong track record and connections then you can raise money with just an idea, but in reality most founders don't have that so the only way they can prove their ability is via their actions and these days that tends to mean at least building something to prove what you're capable of. BTW. Andy Bechtolsheim invested in Google three years after they'd started working on it (as part of their Phd), they'd already launched a public version (google.stanford.edu) with real users by the time he invested. Justin Kan had been working on Kiko for a year before YC invested. Alexis & Steve had been working on MyMobileMenu for a year before they pitched it to YC and PG convinced them to pivot. It's easy to romanticizes away the slog of work that goes in before a startup raises money, but many successful founders had years of work before they raised seed funding.
- oneloop 11y agoThank you for this.
- danieltillett 11y agoI don’t think anyone is disagreeing that a lot of work needs to go into a concept before it can be funded, but Andy still took a lot more risk than the average VC or angel in backing Larry and Sergey when he did.
- ig1 11y agoI believe Google was already in the millions of searches territory by that point. What made Andy a risk taker in that case wasn't the traction (which would still be significant in todays terms with a vastly larger internet population) but rather that search was seen as a dead space. It would have been the equivalent of investing in podcasting in 2013, a space considered played out and dominated by existing players with no significant upside.
- danieltillett 11y agoThere was also the minor point that Larry and Sergey were just a couple of PhD students with no business and no clear path to revenue. Still a gutsy move which many of the current crop of angels and VC would pass on.
- danieltillett 11y agoI just think we need a new term besides "seed" to differentiate it from the true seed investments. I agree. I have been thinking about what to call an investment at the concept stage. The obvious one is “seed bed” (you need a seed bed before you can plant a seed). The other is something combining founder and investor as any investor at the concept stage is really more a founder than an investor - festor doesn’t have quite the ring I would like though :)
- yousifa 11y agoI've been hearing pre-seed rounds (where seed today is what was an A 5 years ago), called "Angel rounds"
- jmorrow977 11y agoWhy not call it a "POC" (proof of concept) round, or "concept round", or "dice round"?
- danieltillett 11y agoConcept round sounds really good. I am stealing it :)
- jmorrow977 11y agoCommenting a long while after the thread was active, but... there's no reason we couldn't rename other rounds too. The seed round could be the "traction round" and the Series A-Z rounds would be the "scale rounds". Before you have traction, you basically just have a concept, so you have a "concept round".
- prostoalex 11y agoThe set of requirements to raise a seed round changes as the set of requirements to launch, test and validate an idea changes. Money from seed rounds in the past would be usually spent in infrastructure and distribution. With cloud providers and app stores that part of equation got changed, so some ideas (not all) can be validated on the cheap. (I believe even one of your examples, Google, existed as a proof of concept product called Backrub, working on Stanford network, before the incorporation event took place). Another point is that investors judge the pitch by the quality of other pitches they heard this day/week/month/year. If you browse AngelList, there are companies raising seed rounds with a functional team, a built-out product, traction and a plan to scale. If someone comes right after them and tries to raise a similar round with nothing but a Powerpoint deck, they will be (even subconsciously) compared against the others.
- hkmurakami 11y ago>Andy Bechtolsheim was a seed investor in Google -- he gave them a check based solely on their idea and who they were. Institutional seed rounds used to not exist (or barely). Thus angels investing to get the company to the A round was aptly called Seed. But now, there are many Seed VC funds around and the size of the round has grown. (and so has the size of the A round) You may recall articles in the past 18 months proclaiming that the Seed round is the new A round. In such an environment, what used to be called the Seed Round can perhaps be called the Angel round. Many startups with credibility (YC, repeat founders, researchers, etc.) may be able to skip the Angel round and go to the Seed round with favorable terms.