4 ms·
> The issue is whether federal land should be used for conservation versus grazing. Correct, that's the issue and the proposed solution is abolishing federal l
by dmix 11y ago
> The issue is whether federal land should be used for conservation versus grazing.
Correct, that's the issue and the proposed solution is abolishing federal land control, transferring rights to state control, and therefore preventing federal intervention in grazing.
>> 'But the stockmen’s ambition went further: they wanted the federal government to transfer control of all federal land, including the national parks, to the states.'
The state legislators would still be free to enforce their own laws in that respect - technically they could themselves limit externalities or even enhance conservation. The parties involved (ie, ranchers) believe that they would be better served at the state level, a belief which was also held by many of those who were behind the constitution - whom they spare no time trumpeting.
- dibujante 11y agoThose parties might have more credibility if their act of protest wasn't wholesale environmental destruction. You can imagine that, were the state to take over, these people would settle for nothing less than the state withdrawing the protected status for this land. It's not about states' rights and never was.
- rayiner 11y agoState versus federal regulation is the means, not the end. The end is cheap grazing land for ranchers at the cost of the environment.
- dmix 11y agoYes but do you see the fallacy in your comment? Whether state vs federal, conservation is similarly a problem that could technically be solved at both levels. Your comment: > "The issue is whether federal land should be used for conservation versus grazing." The real problem IMO is whether states would be better at managing these laws than the federal level. This is what they are proposing... even if they do achieve this, there is no guaruntee that it would instantly turn into a free-for-all for ranchers. There is no clear answer to this question. What if Oregon green-activists acquire similar power, embraces this idea, and do a far better job than the feds at conservation? A model for other states to follow. This is an interesting thought experiment, lost in hyper-political handwaving.