6 ms·
Bill Gates pledges $10bn for a 'decade of vaccine'
- drinian 17y agoFTA: It also estimates that an additional 1.1 million children could be saved with the rapid introduction of a malaria vaccine beginning in 2014. Are we that close to a decent malaria vaccine? I might have to delay some travel plans if that's the case. Biohackers care to comment?
- teej 17y agoRTS,S/AS01 went into Phase III trials in mid 2009. It's being tested solely as vaccination meant for young children and is being tested in East Africa. You can find more information here: http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT00380393 http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT00380393 Until it's tested more extensively for travelers, don't hold your breath for a readily available vaccine. As always, evaluate the malaria risk of your destination and take the appropriate antimalarial for that area.
- LargeWu 17y agoIf his foundation is run anything like Microsoft, their first move will be to develop a polio vaccine.
- mberning 17y agoSounds quite laudable, but I always wonder about the unintended consequences of things like this. Saving millions of lives, particularly in poorer regions, seems like an unpredictable situation at best.
- mattmiller 17y agoWhen someone gets sick they don't just die, they are sick and requiring assistance from others for sometimes long periods of time. This might make the potential productivity of these places higher. I guess the new problem is finding them something productive to do.
- thinkbohemian 17y agoI love this community. I had the exact same question, and couldn't decide if I would be judged as callous for posting it. Here, i find the question posted, and to great replies. Thanks!
- maxwin 17y agoNo, you're not callous. You are just damn ignorant. What you need is a little compassion and try to imagine if you are that poor person and that you mom now gets sick and now try to think should she die just because there's no cheap vaccine ,should she die so that she can sacrifice herself and you can be productive writing your damn programs because you don't need to take care of her. Think About it. Think about it in these people's shoes. They are human beings like you and me. Their sufferings are real. You're saying you can't feel this in your heart? just because you're born in a rich country and all the resources? Yeah, you need to get out of your little world and try to understand not everyone is as lucky as you. And they deserve EVERYTHING you deserve. They shouldn't just die.
- Radix 17y agoYou've misunderstood Matt. When he says "This may increase productivity..." he means vaccines preventing disease will increase productivity, not that his mothers death will increase productivity. He assumes people will take care of their mothers and thus lower their productivity. He's making the same point. This is why you will probably be down voted.
- Seiwynn 17y agoI disagree, simply saving someone's life from a sickness doesn't matter, if they die from starvation because there is not enough food in the country. It is exactly like marciovm123 says, "This sort of spending tugs at the heart strings but unfortunately it can actually be quite counter-productive at improving the lives of people in undeveloped regions." If a country is really that badly off, what difference does it make if we save people from one form of suffering only to have them be subjected to a different form. I agree with some of the above statements that the money would be better spent developing the infrastructure of 3rd world countries, rather than trying to solve a more isolated problem. Simply making vaccines cheaper is treating a symptom and not the problem itself.
- ComputerGuru 17y agoI know you didn't mean to come off so harsh, but what you're saying sounds so very selfish. Who's to decide that person x is to live while person y is to die? Everyone deserves a chance to be the one that lives. Yes, sure, with the famine and the wars and the political problems in these regions it is an interesting thought that perhaps more people will lead to more problems, but it is so very cruel to say that maybe it's best that people die to disease and sickness rather than be given a chance to prove themselves.
- mberning 17y agoYes, you are right, I do believe everybody deserves a chance and we shouldn't allow people succumb to disease as a means of population control. It seems like there are a lot of other pieces to the puzzle that you need to figure out before you introduce a population swell, otherwise you could be creating a generational problem. Save a few million lives today and at the expense of future misery for rather more people. On the other hand, it could work out great and alleviate a lot of the problems that are holding people back in the first place.
- shaddi 17y agoThis is a good point. In fact, the most effective form of population control turns out to be girl's education (both sexual education and otherwise), which reduces the birth rate. High burdens of disease prevent girl's education from happening, especially in regions where there already exists an education imbalance based on gender. Girl's education has a variety of positive non-population control effects as well (consider that without educating women, 1/2 of a nation's population will not be as productive as they would be otherwise). So the current situation is high birth rates with high death rates, which keeps population in a grim equilibrium while the rest of society's resources are spent trying to keep as many people alive as possible rather than engaged in productive development. Reducing the burden of disease is a necessary first step in freeing up these resources to be used in other ways, like girl's education, which will help to alleviate many of the problems of a "sudden" population boom that you mention.
- sp332 17y ago
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- kingkawn 17y agoThere will be no messiah to solve everything at once. You deal with these problems as you can. First the lives to be saved by vaccine are saved, and then they will be alive to face the next round. Sorry its not cleaner.
- fatjonny 17y agoI recently started thinking about this after reading Garrett Hardin's The Tragedy of the Commons essay from 1968 about the "population problem". After reading the essay I started on his 1993 book Living Within Limits: Ecology, Economics, and Population Taboos. I just passed the halfway mark in it, but I highly recommend it if you like his essay and the way he presents ideas. The book really does a good job of covering the evolution of the ideas of population control from Malthus onwards. The essay Lifeboat Ethics: the Case Against Helping the Poor from 1974 is probably the essay available online that is more applicable to the current discussion. I do not yet have a well-formed opinion on this one way or the other, I simply find Garrett Hardin's arguments to be thought-provoking. Saving millions of lives will mean that those millions of lives need to be sustained in some way. The resources to do this have to come from somewhere. By saving those millions of lives is that going to lower the quality of life of millions of others? It is a tough problem with, as Hardin mentions, "no technical solution". Lifeboat Ethics: the Case Against Helping the Poor essay: http://www.garretthardinsociety.org/articles/art_lifeboat_ethics_case_against_helping_poor.html http://www.garretthardinsociety.org/articles/art_lifeboat_et... Tragedy of the Commons essay: http://www.garretthardinsociety.org/articles/art_tragedy_of_the_commons.html http://www.garretthardinsociety.org/articles/art_tragedy_of_...
- maxwin 17y agoIt's not a tough problem. Think about it this way. Imagine you and your mom, your wife , your siblings are born and lived in a poor country. And they get sick. Will you want to save them because they deserve to be alive? Or will you want to let them die just because they could be a burden to the already poor society. Just let all loved one dies? How difficult it is to answer this question? Oh, that's because it's somebody else's moms so just let them die so that the society has enough resources for the rest?
- fatjonny 17y agoThe problem I am referring to in my post is the overall population problem of the world. There are a finite number of resources to sustain the population on this planet and we currently have a very high population growth rate in the world. At some point, the resources we have won't be enough. That is the overall problem. I am fully aware that if someone close to me was sick that I would do what I could to help them. It doesn't change the problem. I was replying to a question about unintended consequences. One of the potentially unintentional consequences of this is that it might make a lot more people suffer in the future overall. It is a tough problem.
- ximeng 17y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1087226 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1087226 The video linked above talks about exactly this issue.
- FlemishBeeCycle 17y agoAlthough not directly related, I found this to be an interesting read (I believe it was posted here a few days ago as well): http://reason.com/archives/2006/03/01/why-poor-countries-are-poor/print http://reason.com/archives/2006/03/01/why-poor-countries-are... It would seem to me that focusing on only one aspect of the hardships suffered by a people is like you said, going to give rise to many unintended consequences. Granted "improving infrastructure" isn't quite as sexy as "providing vaccines", it would probably make more sense to focus on a holistic approach than an isolated problem.
- maxwin 17y agoI come from a third world country and i know that there are tens of millions who are suffering everyday. They are no different than you.We're all human beings. You're just luckier. Bill should definitely get a peace prize for his compassion and generosity.
- tsally 17y agoNo technical people that I'm aware of worship Steve Jobs because of his humanitarian qualities. In fact, if you were to do a broad survey using humanitarian work as a criteria, Bill Gates would be the overwhelming preference. Admiring the charisma of Steve Jobs and the generosity of Bill Gates are not mutually exclusive behaviors. By suggesting that that people "stop worshiping Steve Jobs", you seem to be claiming that they are. Also, "you techies" strikes me as distancing language with a hostile tone. I think you're projecting a broad, unfounded stereotype on people of developed countries. Personally I've very conscious that I was born one of the most advantageous positions in the world. I donate portions of my income with that thought in mind.
- Keyframe 17y agomaxwin here relates to his background and calls for recognition of what bill gates is doing, not mentioning with a single word Steve Jobs. Yet, you've managed to post a rant about him. What is wrong with you? This is like watching guitar playing videos on youtube, where you watch a great guy going at it, playing virtuously some fine piece of music - it's about him, his skill and that piece of music - yet someone posts about some other guitarist how great he is and whatnot. Let me be the one who says this. Who cares about Steve Jobs and Apple and his fans or whatever where we are talking about what Bill Gates and Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation are doing about fixing the shit world we live in. Stop being a teenage girl, this ain't no Backstreet Boys vs East17 or something like that. Though sometimes it is exactly like that and I am truly ashamed of people that behave like that in a group of people I gravitate to. </harsh_rant> edit: apparently maxwin edited his post and I hadn't realized it. My sincere apologies then, but if I'd seen original post by maxwin - a bit altered rant would be directed towards him.
- marciovm123 17y agoI would much rather have Gates spend his money on clean energy research or infrastructure projects. This sort of spending tugs at the heart strings but unfortunately it can actually be quite counter-productive at improving the lives of people in undeveloped regions. By decreasing the amount of wealth that is necessary for a human person to remain alive - for example by introducing a new vaccine that allows a large (5+) family in unsanitary conditions to have all of their children reach adulthood - these sorts of programs in undeveloped countries actually create more poverty then they solve. There is not a cheap-manual labor shortage in these countries. There is however an acute shortage of well-paying jobs that don't involve corruption. By allowing the supply of just-surviving people to increase, you are putting even more downward pressure on the wages of unskilled labor (they are caught in the Iron Law of wages). Keep in mind that in these countries, with no real legal system, unskilled labor doesn't mean gardening like it does in California but violence in the form of gangs/thug-ocracies who typically control access to natural resources or drug running routes. By creating more people, you are making it easier for the systems that keep them poor to grow, in a positive feedback loop. The problem is not that a $3 drug is too expensive, and that we need to develop a 30 cent drug, the problem is that there are people who can't afford $3 for a life-saving drug. What they really need from the US is jobs, markets, and protection from the threats of climate change that we are causing by using 25% of the world's fossil fuels (more if you count the contribution from production in China to the cheap goods that we consume). If Gates really wanted to help these people, he would campaign for an end to developed world farm subsidies, fossil fuel subsidies, and the recreational diamond market. But that would make him unpopular in the US. EDIT: are downvotes for disagreement or for breach of etiquette?
- Kilimanjaro 17y agoFood, shelter, medicine, education, jobs and energy. We should be investing in all of them. But as you say, corruption gets in the way of good will.
- nathanwdavis 17y agoYou might be unaware of how much his foundation has given towards micro-lending and education in poor countries. This vaccine initiative just happens to be the largest of its kind ever. Also, it should be noted that the foundation (according to Wikipedia) specifically targets problems "ignored by governments and other organizations".
- nathanwdavis 17y agoI hope that years from now, Bill Gates will be known more for his contributions to humanitarian aid than for being founder of MS.
- marciovm123 17y agoThat's definitely what he hopes for.
- halo 17y agoHe helped to bring cheap personal computers to hundreds of millions of people, I doubt he needed help sleeping at night or needed his legacy protecting even before his unprecedented philanthropy. I feel the "Microsoft is evil" meme lacks some perspective, even when you consider their biggest misdeeds in the most negative light possible (i.e. crushing competition).
- eande 17y agoThis kind of major undertaking is admirable, because it will reduce suffer and pain to the people who are not so fortunate. The charity contribution I offer is limited and do the best I can through organizations like Kiva.org. I just wish that other well known and well off tech leaders e.g. Larry Ellison, Steve Jobs would be more active. Maybe the Gates Foundation with their actions encourages them to do something on a bigger scale.
- amichail 17y agoWhat about vaccines for the mind? Having harmful ideas infect the mind is often more devastating than most illnesses. See: http://www.reddit.com/r/cogsci/comments/au7t7/why_not_provide_timely_vaccinations_for_harmful/ http://www.reddit.com/r/cogsci/comments/au7t7/why_not_provid...
- jreposa 17y agoI've purchased Windows 3.1, 95, 98, 2000 and XP. I'm finally at peace with that now that I know that part of the money has gone to people really who need it.
- elblanco 17y agoGive the man a prize.
- ecq 17y agoThis is fantastic news. One suggestion though, I would rather spend majority of that $10B in training, building the infrastructure, etc. so that 3rd world countries can produce their own vaccine/medicine/etc. it's sort of like the old Chinese saying: Give a person a fish, and you feed them for a day. Teach a person how to fish, and you feed them for a lifetime.
- alecco 17y agoThis is for image. Their foundation causes great harm indirectly by investing in incredibly evil corporations exploiting and bribing in the third world. And their "voting rights" play is a joke, they are far from significant on any firm (from what I remember, it wasn't the case when the press investigated again; I wouldn't be surprised if they ever voted on any of those evil corporations.) Just read the first paragraphs of the original investigation: http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-gatesx07jan07,0,6827615.story http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-gatesx0... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_&_Melinda_Gates_Foundation#Investments http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_&_Melinda_Gates_Founda...
- maxwin 17y agoSorry to say rude things here. But alecco, you're such an ignorant person. How dare you saying or linking to such lies for these kind of great attempts to save millions of lives.
- alecco 17y agoThanks, but I don't believe in hell. I linked a story from the LA Times and Wikipedia. I didn't add a single thing. On the other hand, Microsoft, while BG was still in command, pushed incredibly evil (in my view) laws in my (developing) country (as in many others) regarding software, costing plenty of money. This doesn't now make it right for me, at all. Note: I don't insult you, I don't wish you bad things, I just think differently and would love to express myself freely granted by our constitution and laws, and yours if you happen to be from USA. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech
- smallblacksun 17y agoFreedom of speech doesn't mean people can't say you're an idiot for what you say.
- alecco 17y ago
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- amvp 17y agoI honestly believe Bill Gates is trying to use the opportunity he has to do improve the lot of humanity. Good for him. However this is a massive opportunity for the vaccine companies who stand to gain a lot (far more than the $10bn) from this. Bill Gates might be in this to make the world better, but they are in it for the profit - and it's reasonable to question their recommendations and motivations. For example look at the Pentavalent vaccine in india: DPT + Hib + Hep B GAVI pays Rs 145 subsidy India pays Rs 380 extra Subsidy for 5 years After that India pays Rs 525 Similarly it's suggested India include a number of new vaccines on their schedule (HPV @ Rs 9000/child, Rotavirus @ Rs 2000/child, and Pneumococcal vaccine @ Rs 650/child), but the situation in India is that 50% of the population don’t receive the basic EPI vaccines costing Rs 30. (not a typo, rs30 vs rs9000). In a nation of limited resources surely the first priority needs to be getting the basic vaccines to the rural poor. But the vaccine companies aren't interested in spending Gates' money on low margin vaccines, they want their foot in the door of a national program. And the WHO and UN unfortunately aren't immune to their pressure. Away from India here's an article about the swine flu 'pandemic' http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,637119,00.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,637119,00.h... If anybody's interested I've half a dozen well cited papers and presentations on the topic of vaccines in India - and they make quite depressing reading. Email in profile.
- nazgulnarsil 17y agoprofit in a market represents simply what people want, and how they value those things in voluntary exchanges. mixing up the concept of "profit" with racketeering, corporatism, cronyism, and making money off of various other involuntary transactions is a huge mistake since it colors your perception of the world.