4 ms·
I doubt that shifting power to the states will solve many problems; after all it's the states that want to force Christianity on students, ban the teaching of s
by nitrogen 11y ago
I doubt that shifting power to the states will solve many problems; after all it's the states that want to force Christianity on students, ban the teaching of science, deny healthcare to those most in need of it, lower standards for students so many HS grads are still illiterate, defund universities, and hand monopolies to oil, mineral, and telecom companies.
- aswanson 11y agoOn top of that, the states horrifically manage what should be simple agencies such as the dmv.
- jerf 11y agoAs with my other reply... do you somehow imagine that all Federal agencies are wonderfully and wisely managed? By what mental gymnastics are you maintaining that belief? Have you ever been critical of Homeland Security? Ever thought our government was too responsive to concerns about terrorists? Ever thought they were responding to climate change incorrectly? Think Obamacare is not everything it should be? Nobody really believes in the existence of this Federal government that you and nitrogen are hypothesizing for solely rhetorical reasons. It's just an argument picked up briefly to advocate for more government, then discarded in the next moment, because you're not willing to live by the rest of its implications (namely, that where you and the Federal government disagree, the Federal government must be correct; if you are not willing to say that clearly, this argument falls apart). It is not rational to compare real state governments to hypothetical federal governments.
- jerf 11y agoWhat on Earth do you think the Federal government is, exactly? By what magic is a government over ten million people to be distrusted, but by aggregating 325 million people's government all of which are also ruled over by these presumably nontrustworthy states, are magically transformed into bastions of sense and sensibility? Where's the line, exactly? It's all the same people! Personally, I think it's just you can sort of imagine a state-sized government, but the Federal government is just inconceivably large so you end up modeling it by what you imagine it could conceivably be, rather than a model that resembles what it is. Other than the fact our Federal government is more interested in fighting Christianity than enforcing it, I could substantiate everything else you said for our Federal government, too. In fact, some of them are clearly more the responsibility of the Federal government right now.
- nitrogen 11y agoNo, some states actually do a good job at some things while other states completely fail at those things. When you mix the good states with the bad states and form a federal government, you reduce the badness in the bad states.