4 ms·
You can absolutely discriminate based on age and gender for insurance purposes, though. Men are charged higher rates than women. Teenagers are charged higher ra
by pc86 11y ago
You can absolutely discriminate based on age and gender for insurance purposes, though. Men are charged higher rates than women. Teenagers are charged higher rates than those in their 20's or 30's. A newly licensed 16 year old male will cost more than a newly licensed 26 year old male. My insurance went down when I got married (which is not outside of my control, but is still a protected class).
If there is valid statistical evidence that a certain group of people (male teenagers with divorced parents, single women in their 40's earning more than $60k a year, divorced white men in Massachusetts, whatever) is likely to behave in riskier behavior for whatever reason, you can bet an insurance company somewhere has the data and is charging accordingly.
- SilasX 11y agoThe parent was saying it was not good, not that it was illegal, as your comment seems to be addressing.
- kdamken 11y agoYou can, but you shouldn't. I hate to use the term slippery slope, but it's crazy to me that they still do this. You could easily apply to same logic to race and prison statistics and how officers treat who they're dealing with, who you hire, etc. Much better to do it on an person by person basis.
- caskance 11y agoIt is much better, that's why insurers try their best to do so. The more data is available, the more feasible that is.
- criddell 11y ago> If there is valid statistical evidence Is that true? Can they charge me a different rate because of my race or religion?
- zygomega 11y agoIt's a grey area legally, and is usually prevented by ethics committees and industry bodies. Practically, if you collect the information you run the risk of a large anti-discrimination suit down the track. The usual proxy for race/religion is first name, last name and zip-code - name clustering gives very strong risk differentiation (I crunch numbers for insurance companies).
- nommm-nommm 11y agoDepends if the jurisdiction you buy insurance in outlaws it. This is a good overview: http://nakedlaw.avvo.com/consumer-protection/why-is-it-legal-to-charge-men-more-for-car-insurance.html http://nakedlaw.avvo.com/consumer-protection/why-is-it-legal...
- nommm-nommm 11y agoWhat is currently legal to do and what is "right" to do are two different things. GP was talking about what "should" be. Of course, a lot of that is opinion that is up for debate. I personally agree. I think charging males more (for example) was only done because we had no way of getting more individualized data. It is all very crude and probably will be an outdated concept in 20 years. *It is illegal to discriminate based on sex for auto insurance purposes in many countries as well as Montana. Insurance companies in most US states take your credit score into consideration (if you don't pay your credit card bill you pay more for car insurance) but this practice is illegal in a handful of states. Massachusetts is one of them, if I recall correctly.