3 ms·
"Consider what could happen if just a single state offered universal basic income, for instance." Roughly the same thing as one country that offers universal b
by jerf 11y ago
"Consider what could happen if just a single state offered universal basic income, for instance."
Roughly the same thing as one country that offers universal basic income but doesn't control its borders, for the exact same reason?
Also, UBI isn't magic. If it would not work in a state individually, it does not become practical by banding 50 states it doesn't work in together. In fact, with the size of most US states, that's just generally true; it is not possible for something to not work in a state due to resource contraints but suddenly become possible when 50 insufficiently-resourced states band together.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoI know I'm contradicting my previous point, but a federal program would inhibit tax-paying citizens and corporations from moving to the most convenient nearby location to do the same business but for cheap. One example to look at would be the cities of Portland, Oregon, and Vancouver, Washington. A lot of people choose to live in Vancouver because Washington has no income tax and spend their time and money in Portland, which has no sales tax. So one could argue that the insufficient resources of a state are a function of the expected tax base exodus if it is cheaper to move and keep doing business than to stay and pay.
- selimthegrim 11y agoThey also spend their time and money in Portland because Vancouver is a hole. And I used to live in St. Johns (AKA Tweakville) so I know whereof I speak.