3 ms·
I have no doubt that there are lots of people who falsely believe they have reactions to MSG. There are lots of people who falsely believe they have reactions t
by shkkmo 11y ago
I have no doubt that there are lots of people who falsely believe they have reactions to MSG. There are lots of people who falsely believe they have reactions to gluten, but that doesn't mean that Celiac's disease doesn't exist.
The problem is that it is incredibly difficult to avoid MSG because it is not required to be labeled as such, but can be hidden behind a large number of other monikers such as 'Natural Flavors'.
- tptacek 11y agoBut it's also incredibly difficult to avoid glutamates because they occur naturally in very high concentrations in some of the foodstuffs people find most palatable, so they make their way into all sorts of recipes. This is similar to the "uncured bacon" phenomenon. Truly uncured bacon wouldn't taste like bacon at all, so producers cure using plant extracts that are naturally high in nitrates rather than in curing salt. The end result is the same, but provides a bogus label that some people take seriously.
- shkkmo 11y ago> also incredibly difficult to avoid glutamates because they occur naturally in very high concentrations in some of the foodstuffs people find most palatable I assume you have some evidence for the 'very high concentration' that indicates the relative levels of concentrations in 'natural foods' compared to the levels that can be found in foods with added MSG? You don't seem to be disputing that people are sensitive to glutamates, so why can't we have clear labeling of when it is added?
- tptacek 11y agoI don't understand this question. Are you really asking whether it's possible to find out how much glutamic acid is in a gram of a given foodstuff? The answer is "yes", of course, just like you can easily find out how much sodium or iron is food.
- shkkmo 11y agoHow? I don't see a 'grams of free glutamate' label on food. I can't even find sources that tell me the average amount of free glutamates in foods where MSG is typically added.
- dawnbreez 11y agoThis is exactly the problem the parent comment describes. Manufacturers aren't required to even mention MSG, or any glutamate for that matter, so we simply don't know.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- yincrash 11y agohttp://nutritiondata.self.com/foods-000093000000000000000.html http://nutritiondata.self.com/foods-000093000000000000000.ht... "Foods highest in Glutamic acid (based on levels per 200-Calorie serving)"
- rhinoceraptor 11y agoWe know that gluten is immunogenic in some people, the controversy is whether the only manifestation of that is Celiac disease. I'm not aware of any plausible mechanism explaining why MSG would cause a laundry list of vague health complaints it's blamed for.