2 ms·
Any argument for a policy that hasn't been tried under current conditions is 'unsubstantiated', so that isn't s valid attack. But.. I think the idea that a gov
by zepto 11y ago
Any argument for a policy that hasn't been tried under current conditions is 'unsubstantiated', so that isn't s valid attack.
But.. I think the idea that a government would allocate the money better than Elon Musk, is indeed suspect. The point here is that Elon Musk is an unusual person.
A more useful question might be - how can we optimize the number of people like Elon Musk who get to execute?
Moving capital to the government probably isn't going to help with that, but concentrating money in the hands of 'investors' is probably not optimal either. In many ways they are just a lesser version of government - a bit less bureaucratic, and a bit more open, but nevertheless not the people who create new wealth. They may have created wealth themselves in the past which is a better qualification than being a politician, but unlike Musk, who is executing himself, for the most part investors are not.
It seems to me that the real constraint is not on who gets to pick winners (govt vs investors), but enabling more people to take a shot.
From that point of view PG's piece is doubly weird, since YC was started from this very premise.
Does the current kind of increasing inequality reduce the pool of people who get to take a shot or increase it? If it reduces if then we need to change something.