6 ms·
What s the current thinking on being able to run Schrödinger's cat backwards? How can time be reversed on something in an indeterminate state?
by mrfusion 11y ago
What s the current thinking on being able to run Schrödinger's cat backwards? How can time be reversed on something in an indeterminate state?
- jsprogrammer 11y agoThe indeterminacy may not be real. It's just that you don't know the state. I don't believe there is a rule that says you get to know everything.
- tbabb 11y agoAre you proposing a "hidden state" which is unobservable? Such a formulation is not consistent with quantum mechanics, as proven by Bell's theorem, unless you permit instantaneous influence from arbitrarily distant parts of the universe.
- jarin 11y agoPut another way, aside from the possible "instantaneous influence" exception above, there are no "hidden variables" or mechanisms under the surface that we just haven't figured out yet. At that level it is truly probabilistic.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoI'm saying that the construction "indeterminate" is only a statement about the knowledge of the person making the statement. Are you proposing that the universe doesn't act unless you are considering it?
- tbabb 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell's_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell's_theorem Certain observations are probabilistic, and the correlations in them predicted by quantum mechanics cannot be reproduced by ascribing them to the traits of particles. It means that at the lowest level, the universe is (barring faster-than-light communication, generally regarded to be false) "truly random". (No concept of an "observer" needs to be devised in order to arrive at this conclusion).
- Houshalter 11y agoHow do you know it's truly random though? Couldn't it be the result of a pseudo random process? Or universe splitting, where two universes are created, one where a coin lands head, and one where it lands tails. To the people inside, it seems random, but it's actually deterministic.
- tbabb 11y agoPseudorandom means the choice is deterministically chosen by according to the state of hidden variables. Bell's theorem says there are no hidden variables that completely explain the predictions of quantum mechanics. A many-worlds interpretation (which is consistent with QM) is basically the same as saying the result is random, because you can't predict exactly which branch any particular interaction will follow.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoYes. This is a known result. If you want to talk about "truly random", please say more. Some theories rule out what you may be calling "truly random".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mrfusion 11y agoAlso perhaps the uncertainty principle in general could present problems reversing time? How would the reversing process know the direction and momentum to reverse for each particle?
- gizmo686 11y agoThe equations that govern quantum mechanics are time reversible, and describes a system of consisting of superimposed states. The Copenhagen (traditional) interpenetration of quantum mechanics posits that when a system gets large enough [0] these superimposed states collapse down to a single state. This interpenetration does pose a problem with time reversibility, as if you run time backwards, then forwards again, it is not guaranteed that you will arrive in the same state after collapse. A more modern interpenetration is Many Worlds. In this interpenetration, there is no collapse. So when we observe the cat, the universe is in a superposition of us having observed a dead cat, and us having observed a living cat. When we run time backwards, we end up at the point where we put the cat into the box, as you would expect. If we run time forwards again, we arrive at the same superposition of observing a living cat, and observing a dead cat. Without looking at the math, the ability to go from a superimposed state to a pure state may seem like it presents an asymmetry, but the equations allow (and we have experimentally done) this in forward time already. As it turns out, the mechanism that allows for this to happen (interference) is the essence of quantum computation. [0] The standard phrasing is is "gets measured". I read this as "gets large enough" because we could, in principle, consider the measurement device to be part of the system.