4 ms·
I would think a lot of inattentive driving would actually show up on the tracker (abrupt stops, swerves). I guess inattentive driving would also result in high
by maxerickson 11y ago
I would think a lot of inattentive driving would actually show up on the tracker (abrupt stops, swerves).
I guess inattentive driving would also result in higher accident rates than attentive driving (which they obviously track).
This is certainly another reason to motivate people to think about what sorts of rules and regulations they want in place regarding data collection and retention.
- jacquesm 11y ago> I would think a lot of inattentive driving would actually show up on the tracker (abrupt stops, swerves). Those could just as well be samples of very attentive driving. You know, the ones where you didn't hit the tourist stepping backwards off the curb into traffic and the one where you avoided the toddler that suddenly appeared between two parked cars (just two samples from my driving career). I'd be more wary of people that never have such items while they drive than the ones that do. Circumstances are everything when it comes to making decisions like these.
- maxerickson 11y agoI think it might be easy. I don't know what the real rates are, but you are suggesting something like 1 adverse event per 10,000 miles (or an even lower rate than that, whatever), to the extent that it is interesting to even bother tracking, I would expect inattentive driving to have a much higher incident rate than that.
- jacquesm 11y agoMuch lower than that, probably more like 1 per 50K or so. But they do happen and depending on where you live they happen a lot more frequently (Romania, for example, where driving is a bit like a video game but you only get one life. (And for pedestrians it is like 'frogger', and they also only get one life.)
- vageli 11y ago>1 adverse event per 10,000 miles This would not be the case in a place like New York City.
- fancyketchup 11y agoThat's why you don't drive 100 mph, mm away from a line of stopped/stopped cars or next to a crowded street corner. Your examples are ones of exactly the type of behavior insurance companies are trying to disincentivize. Namely, fail-deadly behavior that puts you in a position where you have to be attentive to avoid a collision when other actors don't do exactly as they should. Your error was putting yourself in that position in the first place.
- nitrogen 11y agoThat's a pretty big straw man. Even at 8mph if a toddler wanders into the road you are going to have a pretty big jolt from slamming on the brakes. If you've never been driving at or below posted and safe speeds in a neighborhood and still had to slam on the brakes because a child's ball bounces into the street (invariably followed by the child), you are quite lucky. Even with 100 feet to spare, you still slam on the brakes because when a kid wanders into the road, that's what is safest.
- jacquesm 11y agoEven if I would have braked I would have hit the little guy. So I just swerved to the other side of the road. If it had been packed with cars I would have probably killed him, there was absolutely no way the car was going to stop in time. Very bad experience. I got out very fast to scoop the little man+bike out of traffic and hand him back to his mom, we were both shaking like leafs. They're so quick.
- jacquesm 11y ago> That's why you don't drive 100 mph, mm away from a line of stopped/stopped cars or next to a crowded street corner. Wow, you were there? Forgive the sarcasm but you're speaking as though you were when in fact you are utterly clueless about the rest of the circumstances, and you probably are unfamiliar with the local territory. > Your examples are ones of exactly the type of behavior insurance companies are trying to disincentivize. Well, let's just say you are dead-wrong about that. > Namely, fail-deadly behavior that puts you in a position where you have to be attentive to avoid a collision when other actors don't do exactly as they should. Your error was putting yourself in that position in the first place. Classic strawman, you made up an extension to the situation and then you valiantly knock it down. Well done. Really, what would it take to get you to re-phrase your comment into something like: "Forgive me for asking because I don't understand how these situations came to pass in the first place?" And then I would have answered: The tourist was a Japanese dude who was standing right next to one of the most busy streets in Amsterdam, I was doing about 50 kph, right along with the rest of the traffic there (and considerably slower than the taxis overtaking the rest of the traffic) when a guy stepped backwards of the curb while looking through the lens of his camera. Obviously he lost is balance and I stopped the car mere centimeters from his fallen body wrecking a set of nearly new tires in the process. We shook hands and that was that, I'm sure he's going to be a bit more careful in the future while walking and looking through his camera at the same time. The alternative - to swerve - was not an option because of the higher speed traffic in the tram lane and it wouldn't have worked anyway. Good I keep my cars in excellent shape and kudos to whoever designed the brake system on the Citroen DS. The toddler was a much slower affair, this was in a street with slanted parking (quite common in the old south part of the city), this little tike had escaped from his mum and came out from in between two cars well under mirror height. I wasn't going very fast and fortunately there was a large open space on the other side of the road (super market loading area or something to that effect, I forgot) and so I had plenty of room to swerve when I saw something move. At first I thought it was a dog. An emergency stop there would have been too late, he practically rolled out under the car.
- vonmoltke 11y ago> I would think a lot of inattentive driving would actually show up on the tracker (abrupt stops, swerves). How do you separate manoeuvres due to driver inattention from the same manoeuvres due to external causes, such as animals or other drivers being inattentive?