4 ms·
Life expectancy upon reaching adulthood is also a comparison that is frequently done. The arrival of effective hygiene and medicine in the last ~150 years has h
by maxerickson 11y ago
Life expectancy upon reaching adulthood is also a comparison that is frequently done. The arrival of effective hygiene and medicine in the last ~150 years has had a very clear effect on those numbers (a 65 year old US person today can expect to live 6 or 7 years longer than their 1900 counterpart. That's a 65 year old!).
I also think it's tough to correctly estimate the impact of medicine on quality of life. A lot of things in medicine are so effective that we forget they exist (like correcting cleft palate or whatnot).
- Retric 11y agoEarly hunter gathers had fewer communicable disease risks due to vastly lower population sizes. So, for example they did not get the seasonal flue. Consider, there was lot's of EU to America disease spread, but almost nothing went the other way. Despite the fact that south America had fairly large scale farming and population growth. Excluding communicable diseases, most people stay fairly health until 50+ and many hunter gathers likely lived into there early 90's. Infection likely a major risk, but antibiotics are very recent and less necessary than frequently assumed.
- maxerickson 11y agoSyphilis is believed to be a New World disease. I guess I'm not informed enough to start picking a number, but as far as I can tell, the life expectancy upon reaching adulthood has historically been notably lower than it is today, even prior to the horrors of civilization.
- Retric 11y agoThere where a few that made the trip back. But, an estimated ~95+% of people living in the Americas where killed by European diseases. Granted, some of this was deliberate biolocial warfare, and far more people immigrated to the new world than made the trip back. But, even still it's a huge difference. Measles, Smallpox, Typhus, and Cholera for example where all major and easily spread diseases.
- schwap 11y agoAntibiotics aren't the only modern advance to combat infection. Consider also the tools and knowledge (proper wound cleaning and binding) that's been developed to prevent infections in the first place.
- Retric 11y agoTrue enough, but it's internal wounds where antibiotics are most useful. There are also a fair number of Antibacterial herbs for external wound treatment that where in use. Even just honey can be useful. A flowing stream is not sterilized, but can be used for wound treatment, the ocean is also useful for this. The point is it's not as bad as you might think. Consider cavities, without refined sugar and massive quantities of grains there actually far less common. That said, late stage hunter gathers where probably much worse off.
- yoha 11y agoOn the topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEYh5WACqEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEYh5WACqEk
- magicalist 11y agoThis is a weird argument as a benefit to hunter gatherers. The benefits you're discussing are only tied to a hunter-gatherer lifestyle because of low population density. They would have the same issues if they were at the population density we are now...but they couldn't be, because the earth couldn't sustain them. It's definitely not an argument in terms of looking to hunter gatherers for diet or fitness advice, though :)
- Retric 11y agoI agree, I am not saying the lifestyle was overall great or anything. Just that it was better than you might think. Though as to disease it's not just population density. Domesticated animals mostly birds, pigs, and cattle for example created a larger pool to spread disease. Though diseases will spread from primates to humans with minimal contact. PS: You could also have separate populations with minimal contact and have fewer diseases evolve. So, we could have high population density as long as people did not travel or keep animals.