3 ms·People use HMACs to derive keys from passwords? Idiots.by cperciva 17y agoPeople use HMACs to derive keys from passwords? Idiots.randombit 17y agoPBKDF2 uses HMAC. What's the issue here? A PRF seems the right tool for this particular problem, and HMAC happens to be a PRF that has well understood properties.cperciva 17y agoPBKDF2 uses HMAC the same way that multiplication uses addition.randombit 17y agoSo your objection here actually has nothing to do with HMAC at all, but with doing password hashing without iterations?cperciva 17y agoMy complaint is about using a fast PRF where they should be using a slow PRF, yes.