2 ms·
Is it required that they steal the design and idea from the patent documents, and not from the actual product, which almost certainly came out before the patent
by rconti 11y ago
Is it required that they steal the design and idea from the patent documents, and not from the actual product, which almost certainly came out before the patent docs?
- analog31 11y agoNo. Stealing and patent infringement are separate issues. Stealing might be something like walking away with design drawings, source code, etc. This could happen at any time, including before the patent application is filed. Infringement means using the ideas claimed by the patent document. Among the many possibilities, one is that the Chinese company sincerely believes that the US patent application is invalid, for instance if they think that they have discovered prior art. Also, if and when the US patent issues, its claims may bear little resemblance to the application, for instance if the Patent Office discovers prior art. Disclaimer: I'm not a lawyer, but I have a handful of patents.
- droithomme 11y agoThis company filed a provisional patent long before they contacted their first manufacturer. It's a pretty common (and some may say racist) claim to assume chinese company can't invent anything, and that white company never steals anything. But evidence showing either of these claims is lacking. Do you have such evidence? Does anyone?
- analog31 11y agoI was simply using the term "Chinese" and "US" to identify the two parties by their country of origin. And I was just describing what I understand about patents. And I should add as a note: It's only infringement if the patent is valid, something that hasn't been established yet AFAIK.