3 ms·
The only way you can enforce a patent is by having armed law enforcement do so (as they did in this case), or relying on the perception that armed law enforceme
by geofft 11y ago
The only way you can enforce a patent is by having armed law enforcement do so (as they did in this case), or relying on the perception that armed law enforcement could do so.
That said, this argument would essentially hold that to live in civilized society (at least, as we understand civilization), to take advantage of tax-funded things like roads, to make use of government-enforced currencies, etc. is also violence. Which might be technically true, but is not useful, and certainly not useful for the goal of getting the rest of the world to be less violent; I know very few people whose brand of non-violence does not involve attempting to stop other people's violence. Indeed, a serious application of this argument would require one not to use the Internet, which was government-funded (i.e., funded by tax dollars, i.e., funded by money taken at implicit threat-of-gunpoint from citizens) out of military budgets (violence incarnate) and is still a bit government-run, and it would certainly require one not to use Hacker News, given how much Y Combinator firmly requires a strong conception of private property.
So I think our pal Sonic the Hedgehog's famous quote applies, although the context is slightly different: http://i.imgur.com/wi1QIgG.jpg http://i.imgur.com/wi1QIgG.jpg
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoSo I think our pal Sonic the Hedgehog's famous quote applies, although the context is slightly different: http://i.imgur.com/wi1QIgG.jpg* http://i.imgur.com/wi1QIgG.jpg* Well that certainly wasn't expected, but was good for an absurdist chuckle. Why would someone put this together with Sonic? Purely for the absurdity?
- geofft 11y agoI think the backstory there is roughly https://twitter.com/sonic_hedgehog/status/616316157109256192 https://twitter.com/sonic_hedgehog/status/616316157109256192 (The remainder of @sonic_hedgehog is also amazingly absurdist, but usually not particularly anti-capitalist.)
- geomark 11y agoI like your thought process but I think you follow an incorrect path of reasoning because of the implicit assumption that if an act is considered violent it is to be avoided. The world is full of violent people who are only kept at bay by the threat of counter-violence. For that reason, violence is required in a civilized society. So we shouldn't avoid calling it what it is, and should acknowledge it so we can make good decisions about when to apply violence.
- bonestamp2 11y ago> The only way you can enforce a patent is by having armed law enforcement do so Couldn't you just take them to court?
- geofft 11y ago"... or relying on the perception that armed law enforcement could do so." I can take you to court, and you can say, "sure, whatever, you and what army." You'll only care if you think there's an actual army (or police force) who'll make you do what the courts tell you to do. Otherwise any judgment against you doesn't bother you. Note that this is exactly why Chinese knockoffs/counterfeits of US tech products are such a big market: US courts have no jurisdiction in China, and the US Marshals can't keep up with all of the imports.
- supergirl 11y agoMight be true that violence is needed in our civilization. Hard to say; hard to predict the future. But your examples aren't really a good argument. Internet might've been started by anybody. Furthermore, who knows how many great things we didn't do yet because the gov't took our money at gunpoint. And so on.