5 ms·
> It's only the people who did the work and made the stuff who will be laid off. Well... what do you expect? You're either the job creator or the job filler.
by Alupis 11y ago
> It's only the people who did the work and made the stuff who will be laid off.
Well... what do you expect? You're either the job creator or the job filler.
If you could create jobs and had the right motivation and ability to do so, you wouldn't be filling a job.
> Their fault for not cultivating the right connections.
And yes, knowing the right people is part of that game.
And yes, sometimes the job creators must destroy some jobs in order to save the rest. What's better... 10% of Yahoo! laid off... or 100%?
- aaronbrethorst 11y agoYou're either the job creator or the job filler. Please explain to me which one of those labels best applies to the executive team at Yahoo.
- Alupis 11y ago> Please explain to me which one of those labels best applies to the executive team at Yahoo Clearly the former. In 2012 Yahoo had 11,700 employees, and by 2014 they had 12,500 employees.[1] The 10% layoff is going to be around the difference there (so net zero), but I don't think any reasonable person could argue not cutting jobs in this situation would result in a net gain for Yahoo. It's a company in trouble, and it's a reasonable course of action. [1] http://www.statista.com/statistics/260291/number-of-full-time-yahoo-employees/ http://www.statista.com/statistics/260291/number-of-full-tim...
- yeukhon 11y agoAgree, probably just a response to the market, and doesn't actually yield any substantial gain except cutting a 20-30M a year.
- sillysaurus3 11y agoIf you could create jobs and had the right motivation and ability to do so, you wouldn't be filling a job. Haha... I'm happy you believe this. No sarcasm; it just made me wish that I still did. In this world, merit is judged by more than ability. Motive, if not aimed perfectly, is a burden that will decrease your chances, not increase them. Background is so important. My family was totally broken, like one hundred percent shattered. There is no chance I'll be a job creator, no matter how driven. Why can't I meet the right people? Because of what I say when given an initial opportunity. And why am I not able to say the right things? Because of the background and context I grew up in. And I'm not talking about appealing to some rich person and asking for an opportunity. I'm talking about meeting peers, or building a team, or any of the things that really matter. One could argue that this situation is mutable, and that it's mostly my fault for what I say. Obviously, yes, it's my fault for the things I say. But when your whole life has been spent being trained in a certain way, by being in the river of society that pushes us all along, the slipstream that you end up in as a child pretty much makes or breaks your ability to learn how to do anything close to what you're suggesting. To play that game you mention. Enjoy being a job creator. It's an opportunity that you should make the most of, in the stead of all the people who can't.
- Alupis 11y agoThere are many counter examples to your anecdote. Larry Ellison comes to mind, but there are others (in fact, most of our most successful people come from very broken backgrounds). It's what you do with that drive/anger/passion/frustration/motivation/defiance that counts. It takes a lot of risk, and guts to strike out and create jobs - and more often than not it doesn't work out... but that's all part of the game. It's one thing to be really good at what you do... to even be the best. It's another thing entirely to convince other really good and sometimes the best people to work for you, your company, and your ideas.
- sillysaurus3 11y agoCorrelation: Look up Sam's comments about his parents. Think of pg's background. Of the successful people from broken backgrounds, they were usually successful by moving on to affluent universities where they recovered. It's one thing to be really good at what you do... to even be the best. It's another thing entirely to convince other really good and sometimes the best people to work for you, your company, and your ideas. This is in fact the central argument of my original comment: Merit is mostly communication, and your ability to communicate is defined by the context you grow up in. Not in spite of it. When the world shapes you, reshaping yourself is not the only thing that matters. Your old mistakes can brand you for life.
- HillRat 11y agoYour ability to communicate is actually quite exceptional. Whatever has led you to lose faith in yourself, I assure you it should not be because you fear you lack intrinsic merit.
- sillysaurus3 11y agoThank you. I have far less hope than it seems, due to something recent that closed some doors forever. But you made me feel a bit better, if only for a fleeting moment. Please have a wonderful year.
- 11y ago
- jbooth 11y agoIs this poe's law?
- notacoward 11y ago> You're either the job creator or the job filler. That's a very simplistic view. Doing the work and making the stuff also create jobs. How many right here have jobs because developers - not execs, not investors - created the technology we use? Yes, even at Yahoo. Like Hadoop. The idea that the people who contribute money create jobs and the people who contribute labor (in our case via code) don't is utterly, obviously, dangerously wrong. It's self-serving claptrap from those who have no ability to participate in acts of creation instead of arbitrage. No hacker for which this site is named should accept it.
- jevgeni 11y agoI remember seeing a 1970s video from the Soviet Union about a piece of software some soviet scientists developed that could automatically retouch and restore photographs. Like at Adobe Photoshop CC level. What impact did it have? Zero. Because some technocrat apparatchik decided it wasn't worth it developing and promoting the thing further. One can have insane ability to create things, but it will be ultimately futile, if the things created can't sustainably reach consumers.
- notacoward 11y agoOne can have the ability to play middleman, but it will be ultimately futile, if there's nothing to play middleman for. Getting things to consumers first requires that there be a thing, which requires a creative act. Investors and executives can certainly help to facilitate those creative acts, but why should that give them first claim to 99% of the proceeds? It's certainly not a risk premium when those people glide away while the creators get screwed. It's pure rent, in the economics sense.
- jevgeni 11y agoWell, if the creators are so precious and the "middlemen" - not, why just not stop using the "middlemen"?