4 ms·
If they start losing copyright, they start losing back catalog. I doubt there's a huge demand for the 1920s Steamboat Willie [1], but in 2032 they'll lose Snow
by jerf 11y ago
If they start losing copyright, they start losing back catalog. I doubt there's a huge demand for the 1920s Steamboat Willie [1], but in 2032 they'll lose Snow White and the Seven Dwarves and in 2035, Pinnochio.
Of course, that's an awfully long ways off by a time-value-of-money analysis at the rates a modern company would normally use, so the other thing to look at and be... outraged? perturbed? surprised?... at is just how goddamned cheap Congress has historically been. Did you notice this line:
"In one instance, Eisner paid Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott (R-MS) $1,000 on the very same day that he signed on as a co-sponsor."
I mean, I presume that's not necessarily their only cough "donation" to the Senate Majority Leader, but one presumes that the Majority Leader ought to command a price premium, too, and for $1000 to be a notable donation to talk about, well, holy cow. I'd bet Disney wouldn't pay $10 billion as a lump sum in 2023 to extend copyright again... but we're not talking anywhere near that sort of money to get copyright extended. If they can do it for <$10 million, the cost/benefit is a no-brainer.
Remember, the value to Disney only has to exceed their expected costs. If their expected costs for a copyright extension is an accounting rounding error, of course they're going to try to extend it.
[1]: Which, if you've never seen it before, I recommend giving it a view: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BBgghnQF6E4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BBgghnQF6E4 The past is a foreign country!
- ceejayoz 11y ago> I mean, I presume that's not necessarily their only cough "donation" to the Senate Majority Leader, but one presumes that the Majority Leader ought to command a price premium, too, and for $1000 to be a notable donation to talk about, well, holy cow. The limits are pretty low on individual donations. http://www.fec.gov/info/contriblimitschart1516.pdf http://www.fec.gov/info/contriblimitschart1516.pdf For 2015-2016, you can only give $2,700 to a specific candidate as an individual.
- HillRat 11y agoThat's what bundlers are for -- it's amazing how many corporate employees are willing to ante up to the maximum limit amount. Sometimes even folk making fifteen bucks an hour. Very civic-minded, they are. Less cynically, most contributions aren't about bribery for legislation (superPACs looking increasingly like an exception), but about simple access, ensuring that your calls get returned and your point of view is at least heard. It's still quite arguably a corrupt system, but the corruption is slightly abstracted from the simple act of giving money.
- jellicle 11y agoAnd then you can also donate much more to the various party committees, and you can do it as a "directed donation", so that the money is credited to Politico X and the party committee immediately forwards the money back to Politico X. But corruption talk that centers on the individual donations made to politicians is mostly wrong. That's not how corruption works. That's a reflection through a mirror of the actual corruption happening, which is mostly about influence, not money. Politico A and Entity B have made a deal to use their influence to support each other, and that is reflected in some puny $1000 donation somewhere, but it's not mostly about the $1000.
- gene-h 11y agoWell if congress is really that cheap, perhaps someone should make a kickstarter to buy back our government.
- lotu 11y agoYou mean raise the salery of congress? Literally no one wants to do that.
- placeybordeaux 11y agoI think they mean start lobbying.
- tamana 11y agoLessig tried: Mayday PAC
- danieltillett 11y agoI think it is time to try again.
- brianclements 11y agoI think it's time to never stop trying.
- hkmurakami 11y agoA friend of mine [1] has been building something that is exactly what you describe: https://www.shiftspark.com/content/how-it-works https://www.shiftspark.com/content/how-it-works "We allow people to speak to their politicians. And not just during campaign season. By pledging money, ShiftSpark lets you signal the issues tied to your support when politicians need it - BEFORE the election. This gives us more candidates, less corporate influence and politicians who listen." [1] He was previously the president of the Manhattan Young Democrats and is currently a Vice President at the Young Democrats of America.
- 11y ago
- throwawayhdhe 11y agoMost people do not understand how cheap it is to buy laws. It is much more expensive to compete in an open and free market than it is to buy a barrier to entry etc. Just another example of the corrupt state of American governance.
- hkmurakami 11y agoAs much as I hate the idea of lobbying as it works today, I can't deny the tremendous ROI that it represents for companies like Intuit whose entire business relies on convoluted, complex tax laws. TurboTax Maker Funnels Millions To Lobby Against Easier Tax Returns http://techcrunch.com/2013/03/27/turbotax-maker-funnels-millions-to-lobby-against-easier-tax-returns/ http://techcrunch.com/2013/03/27/turbotax-maker-funnels-mill...
- derefr 11y agoPresumably, lobbying is cheap if there's nobody tugging in the opposite direction. $1000 would convince pretty much anyone to vote a certain way on an issue they're neutral/undecided on. On the other hand, $1000 probably won't "buy back" a vote that e.g. the oil lobby bought for $1mm.
- cookiecaper 11y agoIt's obviously not about the money. Ignoring the obvious fact that a massive monetary transfer would not be seen kindly by regulators, politicians employ the connections that they made while serving to make gobs of money for themselves after they leave office. Having Disney's CEO in your rolodex and owing you a favor is worth a lot more than any immediate monetary award.
- jacquesm 11y ago> but in 2032 they'll lose Snow White and the Seven Dwarves and in 2035, Pinnochio. As derivative works those should never have been afforded the level of protection they got.
- thebiglebrewski 11y agoI mean, what if we looked at it in another way? What if we could use that $10 billion to pay teachers better in poor school districts around the country? How impactful would that be just to not have the ability to make cartoons with one specific character? And people parody Mickey anyway and if it complies with parody law and isn't SUPER offensive, the Mouse would probably just send a cease and desist. If corporations are already buying the government and avoiding taxes...why can't we put that money to the public good?
- jerf 11y agoA variety of solutions involving permitting extensive relicensing on some sort of exponential scale have been proposed, but it's all just pointless academic speculation as long as Disney can just keep buying extensions. It does seem to me that we could possibly reach a compromise with Disney in that respect; to be honest, I don't really care whether Mickey falls into the public domain anytime soon anymore. But it's stupid to hold the entire culture hostage for the vanishingly small percentage of things from the early 20th century that are still ongoing commercial concerns.