> As for T-mobile, BingeOn is optional and can be disabled anytime with just a click, so it does little to nothing to hurt customers and cannot effectively be c

> As for T-mobile, BingeOn is optional and can be disabled anytime with just a click, so it does little to nothing to hurt customers and cannot effectively be called throttling. It's still throttling, from what I read. If it's optional throttling at the user's control and at no price difference, then you have a point in that it's not unfair or unreasonable, but only if customers actually understand that it is throttling so that they know to turn it off. If they don't know that they're being throttled, then the ability to turn it off is moot; they effectively don't have the ability at all. And in that case users are being unreasonably and unfairly throttled.