3 ms·
I'm not sure how I feel about this. I mean, Binge On is obviously targeted at customers who have limited data plans and seem likely to go over their cap if the
by fastball 11y ago
I'm not sure how I feel about this.
I mean, Binge On is obviously targeted at customers who have limited data plans and seem likely to go over their cap if they watch video normally. Many (most?) streaming sites don't provide fine-grained control over what quality is delivered to your device. Seems like a lot still just differentiate between "normal" and "HD". So it seems to me like T-Mobile is trying to help their limited customers out by lowering the bandwidth on videos so that data is used up a slower rate. I personally have an unlimited data plan, so I can't even provide anecdotal evidence, but if I had a limited plan, I think I would appreciate that.
Once bitrate management is in place, throttling doesn't seem like a big deal. As long as I am still being delivered data at a rate > the rate at which I am consuming the video (i.e. as long as there is no buffering) then there isn't really a problem, right?
If you disagree with T-Mobile's decision to choose what bitrate is good for you, then yeah, I understand, this sucks. If, on the other hand, you are OK with this, then I don't really think there is an issue.
What I think would be the best option would be for T-Mobile to have some sort of control panel that customers could use to pick a bitrate cap for all videos that they watch on their mobile plan. Seems like that could please both parties if they started with a fairly restrictive default setting but users could change it.
- shkkmo 11y agoThe problem is that Binge On is not just 'choosing what bitrate is good for you' but is also throttling all video data, including direct downloads. > The EFF post found that T-Mobile isn’t actually “optimizing” any video traffic for Binge On users, it’s merely throttling it. Not all video players on all websites have the capability to down-res a video from, for example, 1080p to 480p. That means some videos on some websites using some players must be watched at their original resolution (due to T-Mobile’s guidelines, these will inherently not be Binge On services). Even though this hypothetical 1080p video would count against both a Binge On customer’s data cap and a non Binge On customer’s data cap, one without Binge On will stream the 1080p video at a speed as fast as the network can go; one with Binge On will stream it at 1.5 Mbps, a speed that makes it arguably un-streamable. http://motherboard.vice.com/read/t-mobiles-binge-on-indiscriminately-throttles-all-video-content http://motherboard.vice.com/read/t-mobiles-binge-on-indiscri... I've been a fan of John Legere's antics and efforts to push for innovation in the US carrier industry. However this sort of attack on the EFF and blatant lying/misinformation about throttling is a shyster move.
- fastball 11y agoWow. I hadn't read that one. Very interesting. I was giving them the benefit of the doubt, but this does seem very damning.
- OrwellianChild 11y agoWith current video streaming services and current mobile devices not providing an easy way to limit bandwidth for video, this totally optional service seems to be putting that power into consumer hands... If you don't like it, you can shut it off: https://support.t-mobile.com/docs/DOC-24294 https://support.t-mobile.com/docs/DOC-24294 If you're not tech savvy and don't know about the feature, your experience of throttled HD video may be impacted. Any calls to service or visits to company stores will alert you to what is happening and will give you remedies. This seems to me like a reasonable compromise that meets the needs of both low-data-cap consumers and a company that wants to minimize cost of providing data services... I don't understand what is "shyster" about this.