3 ms·
Freezing the account is not, in and of itself, what makes this incredibly unethical. It's trying to sell a loan after freezing the account. That creates an eno
by smt88 11y ago
Freezing the account is not, in and of itself, what makes this incredibly unethical. It's trying to sell a loan after freezing the account.
That creates an enormous conflict of interest for the people at PayPal who decide when to freeze/unfreeze an account.
- omfg 11y agoIt's just an automated ad promoting a product. I'm sure that company saw other ads when logging in on different days. Is it silly that they advertise it on high risk accounts? Maybe.. but it's nothing nefarious.
- PixelB 11y agoAccording to the article, PayPal claimed that it was not an automated ad and they were in fact eligible for it. "To paraphrase: “It may seem weird that we’re holding collateral on your account and offering you a loan, but that was not a mistake! You’re still eligible. Contact me if interested.”"
- URSpider94 11y agoThey didn't claim it wasn't automated. They just claimed that it isn't a mistake. The better explanation is that the criteria for a hold and the criteria for a loan are not one and the same.
- chris_wot 11y agoHence the concerns over a conflict. Whilst the risk to PayPal may be deemed acceptable to PayPal, the only reason you would need the loan is because they froze Tor funds. They are not just managing your risk, they are increasing it whilst mitigating the effects it has on themselves!
- URSpider94 11y agoMy point is, I don't believe they are offering the loan because the company is in financial trouble (due to the hold). I believe they are offering the loan because the company meets certain requirements in terms of transaction volume. Companies can reach the required transaction volume without having holds on their account.
- cwyers 11y ago> They are not just managing your risk, they are increasing it whilst mitigating the effects it has on themselves! Well, they're passing the risk on. The risk is in chargebacks from people who bought things from the OP's company, right? If they weren't using PayPal or some other third-party payment processor, that would be their risk.
- smt88 11y ago> Well, they're passing the risk on Yes, but PayPal gets a (high) transaction fee in exchange for assuming that risk. The company borrowing from PayPal is charged interest for the privilege of taking that risk away from PayPal. That's insanely exploitative on PayPal's part.
- smt88 11y agoI don't see why it matters whether it was automated or not. Either way, PayPal has a huge conflict of interest by A) creating a situation where a business needs a loan and B) selling loans.
- emeraldd 11y agoThis a thousand times over ...
- tyingq 11y agoSounds exactly like a protection racket to me. Artificially create an urgent need for a service, then sell the service.
- mcv 11y agoI think the freezing is unethical. It's not PayPal's money. The customers didn't intend that money for PayPal, but for the merchant. Taking money that isn't yours is theft in my book. Does PayPal even pay interest over the money it denies their customers?