4 ms·
This sounds pretty crazy, but is it possible for the Chinese government to manipulate the American stock markets by playing with its own stock market? China kn
by chatmasta 11y ago
This sounds pretty crazy, but is it possible for the Chinese government to manipulate the American stock markets by playing with its own stock market?
China knows that when its markets plunge, the American markets plunge too.
Is there a way for China to create the illusion of its markets plunging, without losing real value (or at least profiting from the perspective of some influential power in China)? Perhaps they could accomplish such manipulation through a combination of 1) collusion between the CCP and the largest investors in the Chinese market, 2) currency manipulation, and 3) shorting of US equities?
I know this sounds speculative and vague, because honestly I have no idea what I'm talking about. But China certainly has the motive to manipulate American markets. And since the foreign investment is asymmetrical (e.g. the Chinese can invest in NYSE, but Americans cannot invest in Shanghai), China has an opportunity to "play both sides" of a Shanghai market crash and any corresponding American market drop, while American investors cannot do the same.
So... is it possible?
- justinhj 11y agoBut China wants its people to feel wealthy. The property boom ended, then there was gold boom. They wanted a stock boom. People that feel wealthy are happy citizens. They have every reason to keep the stock market high.
- mooreds 11y agoThe current government doesn't want to lose the Mandate of Heaven: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandate_of_Heaven https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandate_of_Heaven They know their history.
- duaneb 11y agoI mean, you could say the same thing every year for any ruling party for the past millenium. I'm not convinced it's at all relevant to the conversation any more than any government beholden to its people.
- mooreds 11y agoI think the Chinese tradition of accepted regular popular revolt makes this possibility weigh more heavily on the communist party's collective mind than, say, that of the Indian ruling party.
- arasmussen 11y agoWhile an interesting thought, this seems crazy, paranoid, and self-centered to me. The world doesn't revolve around America. The Chinese government certainly cares a load more about its own economy doing great than how other economies are doing. They wouldn't sabotage their economy and destroy trillions of dollars in wealth to make a significantly lesser dent in our economy.